Why Malachi Toney has to be an early Heisman favorite after dominant Miami debut

One September performance should not decide the Heisman Trophy. It can, however, show who is leading the race. After what Malachi Toney did in No. 7 Miami football’s season-opening 45-6 win at Stanford, any early Heisman conversation that excludes him is already incomplete.

Toney caught 12 passes for 234 yards and three touchdowns, doing all of his damage in three quarters. He scored on the Hurricanes’ first two possessions, reached halftime with 10 receptions for 182 yards, and finished his night with a 47-yard touchdown. That final catch pushed him past Eddie Brown’s 42-year-old single-game school record of 220 receiving yards. His 95 yards after the catch further demonstrated that his production was not solely due to the scheme.

That is more than a spectacular stat line against an overmatched opponent. It is the type of loud, nationally televised performance a non-quarterback needs to begin building a Heisman campaign. Toney did not merely benefit from broken coverages or from empty production after the outcome was settled. He became the center of Miami’s offense immediately and turned his first game with Darian Mensah into the best receiving performance in program history.

The Stanford blowout alone does not justify declaring Toney as a favorite. His established resume does.

As a true freshman, he led the country with a school-record 109 receptions. He added 1,211 receiving yards, 10 touchdown catches, 113 rushing yards, 298 punt-return yards, and two touchdown passes. Toney then came through for 10 catches for 122 yards and a touchdown vs. the Indiana Hoosiers in the national championship game. Friday did not introduce a sudden breakout. It indicated that one of the nation’s best players has become even more dangerous.

The speedy sophomore also has the traits needed to overcome the Heisman’s usual quarterback preference. He can win from the slot or outside, create after the catch, and affect games as a runner, passer, and returner. That versatility gives the Hurricanes offense several ways to keep him involved when stronger defenses attempt to remove him from the passing game.

The path remains difficult. The Cardinal will not be the opponent that defines his season, and Toney must sustain elite production when Miami reaches the demanding part of its schedule. Mensah, who completed 27 of 30 passes for 401 yards and five touchdowns, could also develop a candidacy of his own.

Still, that partnership should strengthen Toney’s case more than it threatens it. Miami has a quarterback capable of maximizing his best weapon and a team expected to contend for the College Football Playoff. Recent winners DeVonta Smith and Travis Hunter showed that dominant receiving production can break through when it is paired with team relevance and unforgettable moments.

Toney already has all three. He did not win the Heisman on opening night, but he unquestionably earned a place among its earliest favorites.

The post Why Malachi Toney has to be an early Heisman favorite after dominant Miami debut appeared first on ClutchPoints.