Steelers’ perfect Brian Thomas Jr. trade offer if Jaguars move on from former 1st-round pick

The Pittsburgh Steelers can’t afford to stall after Mike Tomlin’s farewell. They are entering unfamiliar territory. For nearly two decades, Tomlin provided stability, culture, and consistency. Now, the franchise’s next era under Mike McCarthy demands more than just maintaining standards. It demands evolution.

If Pittsburgh wants to bridge the gap between regular-season competence and postseason credibility, it must inject explosiveness into an offense that may or may not feature Aaron Rodgers. And if the Jacksonville Jaguars are indeed willing to move on from Brian Thomas Jr, the Steelers should be first in line.

End of an era

The 2025 Steelers season was a study in transition and resilience. Rodgers stabilized a quarterback room that had been in flux for years. The result was a 10-7 record and Pittsburgh’s first AFC North title since 2020. Rodgers’ chemistry with offseason acquisition DK Metcalf gave the offense a vertical punch that had been missing.

The fairytale, however, ended abruptly. A 30-6 Wild Card loss to the Houston Texans exposed familiar flaws. These were limited offensive versatility and an inability to keep pace in playoff shootouts. The campaign carried added emotional weight. It marked Tomlin’s final season. He extended the franchise’s remarkable streak to 22 consecutive non-losing seasons before announcing he would step down.

Uncertainty and flexibility

Rodgers’ potential retirement may leave Pittsburgh with Mason Rudolph and developmental project Will Howard as the only quarterbacks under contract. This creates urgency for general manager Omar Khan.

Fortunately, Pittsburgh is well-positioned to act. The Steelers project to hold roughly $42.5 million in effective cap space. That gives them room to absorb contracts or pursue a trade for a veteran signal-caller. More importantly, they possess 12 draft selections in 2026, including five inside the first 100 picks.

The 21st overall pick headlines the arsenal, but the true power lies in the depth of Day 2 capital. That flexibility allows Khan to address multiple needs without sacrificing the future. Of course, quarterback will dominate headlines. However, surrounding whoever starts under center with speed and vertical threat may be equally vital. That’s where Brian Thomas Jr enters the equation.

Brian Thomas Jr’s complicated 2025

Thomas Jr burst onto the scene in 2024 with over 1,200 receiving yards and 10 touchdowns. He instantly flashed WR1 upside. His sophomore season, though, told a different story. In 2025, he managed 48 receptions for 707 yards and just two touchdowns in 14 games. An ankle injury sidelined him for three contests. Early-season drop issues also plagued his efficiency. At one point, he had one of the highest drop rates among qualified receivers.

The Jaguars’ evolving offensive structure didn’t help. With Parker Washington emerging and Jakobi Meyers added to the mix, Thomas increasingly found himself relegated to a WR3 field-stretching role. He still displayed big-play flashes and capped the year with a postseason touchdown against Buffalo.

In Jacksonville, though, he’s now an expensive depth piece. In Pittsburgh, he could be something more.

Why both teams do the deal

For Jacksonville, this is about asset optimization. With Travis Hunter emerging as a two-way centerpiece and Meyers secured long-term, Thomas has become somewhat redundant. Moving him now allows the Jaguars to recoup draft capital before committing to any contract option. In a roster recalibration phase, maximizing value is smart business.

For Pittsburgh, it’s about acceleration. The Steelers can’t waste a transition year under McCarthy hoping for incremental growth. Thomas would perfectly complement Metcalf’s physical dominance. Together, they create a track-meet dynamic capable of stretching defenses horizontally and vertically.

With 12 draft picks, Pittsburgh also has ammunition to spend without mortgaging flexibility.

Perfect trade framework

To acquire a former first-round pick who has already demonstrated WR1 flashes, Pittsburgh must offer legitimate Day 2 capital.

The proposed deal:

• The Steelers receive wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr.
• The Jaguars receive a 2026 third-round pick, a 2026 fourth-round pick, and wide receiver Roman Wilson.

This structure checks every strategic box.

Why it makes sense

First, the draft capital. Pittsburgh holds three third-round picks in 2026. Surrendering one along with a fourth is a manageable price for a 23-year-old receiver with Thomas’ ceiling. It’s a calculated investment rather than a reckless splash.

Second, the fresh-start component. Wilson’s tenure in Pittsburgh has not unfolded as expected. Including him provides Jacksonville with a cost-controlled slot option and gives Wilson a reset in a new environment. It balances the asset exchange while addressing depth concerns for both teams.

Third, the financial practicality. Thomas carries a modest $3.99 million cap hit in 2026. For the Steelers, this is an incredibly cost-effective addition. Pittsburgh gains explosive upside without compromising cap flexibility needed for future quarterback moves.

Pittsburgh’s bigger picture

This isn’t just about acquiring another receiver but about redefining identity. A McCarthy-led offense thrives on spacing and vertical aggression. Thomas’ ability to threaten deep coverage opens intermediate lanes for Metcalf along with tight ends Pat Freiermuth and Jonnu Smith. It also creates easier reads for whichever quarterback takes over in 2026.

In today’s AFC, you don’t win by grinding out 20-17 victories alone. You win by forcing defensive coordinators into impossible coverage decisions. Metcalf and Thomas together would do exactly that.

The Steelers are entering a new chapter. They have the cap space and draft capital. What they need now is conviction.

Brian Thomas Jr may not be the league’s hottest trade commodity. However, he represents a rare combination of youth, speed, and proven production potential. For a manageable price, Pittsburgh could secure a long-term vertical weapon who fits seamlessly into its evolving offensive blueprint. Right now, the Steelers just can’t afford caution.

The post Steelers’ perfect Brian Thomas Jr. trade offer if Jaguars move on from former 1st-round pick appeared first on ClutchPoints.