Best betting promos and sportsbooks for MLB prop bets [May 11, 2026]

May 11, 2026 - 11:45

The New York Yankees kick off Monday night’s small slate of games with a divisional matchup against the Baltimore Orioles.

After a slow start to the year, the New York Yankees have started to turn into one of the more formidable units in the league by making contact at a more consistent rate.

Luckily for the Yankees, their lineup will have the opportunity to build on their momentum against the Baltimore Orioles, battling it out against Brandon Young who struggles with avoiding contact.

With six games taking place on Monday night, there are plenty of prop bets and markets to wager on which you can read a detailed breakdown of them below.

Best betting promos and sportsbooks for MLB prop bets

Find the best promos and sportsbooks to use for today’s MLB prop bets.

New York Yankees vs Baltimore Orioles (6:35pm, EST)

Brandon Young Over 5.5 Hits Allowed (+105) at BetMGM Sportsbook

In his brief appearances on the mound, Brandon Young has struggled to find his footing, kicking off his 2026 campaign with a WHIP of 1.452 and a FIP of 4.82.

His underwhelming start to the year can be attributed to his low Whiff Rate, generating less than one Strikeout and more than one Hit Against per Inning Pitched.

In a AL East divisional matchup against the New York Yankees, expect Young to continue to struggle with avoiding contact, battling it out against a star studded lineup who ranks above league average in Hit Rate, Walk Rate, and in On Base Percentage.

Especially with the Orioles back end severely underwhelming in coverage, surrounding Young with a group who ranks in the bottom five in Defensive Efficiency and in Fielding Percentage.

Brandon Young Under 15.5 Outs (-129) at Caesars Sportsbook

With the Yankees consistently threatening to get into scoring position by stringing together their Hits, Young’s leash on the mound will drastically shrink, increasing the likelihood he is pulled early on in his start to help the Orioles avoid falling further deep into a hole.

If the total on Young’s Outs prop crosses through the key number of 15.5, then reduce the size of your wager.

Seattle Mariners vs Houston Astros (8:10pm, EST)

Peter Lambert Over 4.5 Strikeouts (-110) at BetMGM Sportsbook

While not much has gone right for the Houston Astros two months into the season, Peter Lambert has been one of their lone consistent sources of success, averaging an ERA of 2.42, a WHIP of 1.164, and a FIP of 2.82.

Even when receiving minimal support from his back end who struggles in coverage, Lambert has still been able to avoid contact by generating Whiffs, averaging over one Strikeout per inning.

Heading into Monday night, Lambert will be able to mask his back ends struggles in coverage with his own individual production on the mound as he faces off against the Seattle Mariners who rank below league average in Hit Rate and in Strikeout Rate.

For some more exposure, escalator bet Lambert’s Strikeout prop by placing smaller wagers on his alternate overs.

Cal Raleigh Under 0.5 Hits (+125) at BetMGM Sportsbook

Since the start of the regular season, Cal Raleigh has been unable to get into a groove, generating less than one Hit per game, a .161 Batting Average, and a .573 OPS.

With Lambert aggressively attacking the plate without making contact, expect Raleigh to continue to struggle to barrel up the ball and be held without a Hit on Monday night.

San Francisco Giants vs Los Angeles Dodgers (10:10pm, EST)

Los Angeles Dodgers Team Total Under 4.5 (+100) at BetMGM Sportsbook

After going 4-6 in their last ten games, the Los Angeles Dodgers odds of winning the NL West have steadily dipped, now tied with the San Diego Padres for first in the division standings.

Even during their recent skid, the Dodgers have been able to thrive on offense, fielding a group who ranks in the top-6 in Hit Rate, RBIs, Runs Scored, On Base Percentage, and in OPS.

Unfortunately for the Dodgers, negative regression looms large in their divisional matchup against the San Francisco Giants as they face off against Trevor McDonald who is currently averaging an ERA of 1.29 and a WHIP of 0.286.

Even with his back end struggling to hold their own in coverage, McDonald is capable of neutralizing the Dodgers at the plate, generating less than one Hit Against per inning.

About the author

Kody Malstrom

Kody Malstrom is a professional sports bettor and sports betting journalist with six years of experience covering a vast majority of sports. He covers football, basketball, hockey, baseball, and the UFC in written and video form.

Born and raised in Michigan, Kody is a Detroit sports fan who spends all of his Sundays in the fall rooting for the Detroit Lions and Saturdays watching as much College Football as possible. In the winter, he shifts his focus to the Detroit Red Wings and Pistons while simultaneously rooting for his North Carolina Tar Heels.

When he is not staring at betting markets, you can find Kody at the beach or snowboarding down a mountain, depending on the time of the year.

Commercial content notice: Taking one of the sportsbooks offers featured in this article may result in a payment to talkSPORT. 21+. T&Cs apply. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler