The Indianapolis Colts are officially having a fire sale. Indy traded All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson to Seattle on Tuesday in exchange for multiple draft picks. The trade activity may soon pick up again, as Indy is actively shopping DeForest Buckner as well. It is not too surprising to see Nelson moved, but it is a bit shocking that it came together so quickly.

The NFL's trade deadline is on November 10th, but the Seahawks clearly did not want to wait that long. Now Seattle gains an excellent offensive lineman who will help them compete for a playoff spot in the NFC. Meanwhile, the Nelson trade calls everything into question for the Colts after falling to 2-5 on Sunday.

So what should fans make of this trade? Was it a good deal for both teams, or was it more one-sided than that?

Here are trade grades for both teams after this massive trade two weeks before the NFL trade deadline.

Colts kick off fire sale by sending away Quenton Nelson

This deal could have massive ramifications for what comes next for the Colts. But let's stick to talking about the terms of the deal first before getting into that.

Indy acquired a 2027 third-round pick and a 2028 fifth-round pick in exchange for Nelson. That is a solid return, as it gives the Colts a bit more than they could have received by simply playing the compensatory pick game. It also guarantees they have more ammo ahead of what could be a loaded 2027 draft class.

Nelson was on an expiring contract and the Colts likely could not afford to retain his services. Therefore, it is a smart move by interim general manager Ed Dodds to get something in return for him.

The Colts will now have seven selections in the 2027 NFL Draft after accounting for the Seahawks' third-round pick. Unfortunately, they still won't have a first-round pick after the Sauce Gardner trade. That puts the Colts in quite the bind when it comes to making team building decisions next spring.

Now that Nelson has been traded, the Colts will receive more trade calls on other players. It will be fascinating to see how many additional players they move before the deadline.

Ultimately, the real grade for Indy should come in the future after they finish their fire sale. But judging this trade purely in a vacuum, it is a solid move.

Grade: B

Seahawks make huge upgrade on the offensive line at a reasonable price

This trade is a smashing success for Seattle.

The offensive line has not been a strength for the Seahawks in a long time. It has improved during the Mike Macdonald era, with Charles Cross and Grey Zabel both being massive investments. Now the Seahawks add what could be the final piece of their o-line in Nelson.

Adding Nelson moves Anthony Bradford out of the starting lineup and makes him an incredible backup. Seattle has plenty of beef on the interior, which could help improve their ailing running game. The addition of Nelson, plus the eventual return of Zach Charbonnet, could really get the ground game working for the Seahawks.

Article Continues Below

There's also the fact that Sam Darnold will now have better protection on the interior.

As for the financial side of things, this looks like a smart move by Seattle's front office. Nelson is on an expiring contract and only holds a $9.78 million cap hit for the rest of this season. He will only be 31 years old next season, so it is reasonable to expect he can continue playing a high level.

Seattle has $31.62 million in cap space in 2027 and $133.55 million in 2028. That gives the Seahawks some incredible flexibility for dictating his future with the team.

If the Seahawks simply want to ride out the rest of Darnold's contract and go from there, they can sign Nelson to a short-term deal. Or if they are confident that he's worth a long-term deal, they can sign him to one. Seattle could even use Nelson as a one-year rental, let him hit free agency, then potentially pocket a compensatory draft pick in the future.

Either way, Seattle wins. That's what makes this such a great move by the defending Super Bowl champs.

Grade: A+