The Washington Commanders are off to a rough start in the 2026 NFL season, and their upcoming game against the San Francisco 49ers could help determine the team's direction. If Washington cannot turn things around, the front office should consider becoming a seller before the Nov. 10 trade deadline. Defensive tackle Daron Payne is one player who could bring back a useful return.
Payne is in his ninth season with Washington and has built a strong résumé during his time with the team. He has recorded more than 440 total tackles, 38 sacks, and eight forced fumbles. He also has an interception from 2020. His ability to stop the run and pressure quarterbacks makes him a potential target for teams looking to improve their defensive line before the playoffs.
However, the Commanders must decide whether keeping Payne for the rest of the season is worth passing up a chance to acquire future assets.
1 Player Commanders Must Trade
Washington's start to the 2026 season has been disappointing, and the team's recent tie against the New York Giants showed some of the discipline problems that have hurt it. The Commanders still have time to get back into the playoff race, but they need to start winning soon. A loss to the 49ers would drop them to 1-4-1 and leave them with little room for more mistakes.
If the team continues to struggle, trading Payne should be part of the conversation. He is in the final year of his contract and is 29 years old, which could make him a useful addition for a contender looking to improve its defensive line for the stretch run. A trade would also give Washington a chance to receive compensation rather than risk losing him in free agency.
Defensive tackles who can stop the run and contribute as pass rushers have value around the league. Payne has experience in both areas, and Washington should find out what other teams are willing to offer. Draft picks could help the Commanders address multiple needs as they work to build a more competitive roster.
Of course, trading Payne is not the only option. Washington could negotiate an extension and keep him in its plans beyond 2026. Retaining a player with his experience and production would make sense if the organization believes it can get back on track. Replacing his role on the defensive line would not be easy, either.
Article Continues BelowStill, the Commanders must be realistic about their position. If they keep losing and fall further out of playoff contention, the front office should focus on the future. Holding onto a veteran on an expiring contract may not be the best move if the team is unlikely to compete this season.
There are teams who could use his services like the Dallas Cowboys, Green Bay Packers, and Atlanta Falcons, while teams who already have a strong defense like the Houston Texans and San Fransico 49ers could be interested.
Payne has spent nearly a decade with Washington, but that should not stop the organization from considering a trade. The deadline gives the Commanders a chance to turn a player who may leave in free agency into assets they can use to improve the roster.
If Washington cannot get its season back on track, Payne should be one of the first players the team considers moving. The Commanders could still pursue an extension, but they should explore the trade market before that opportunity passes.