This game was a mess thanks for the refs.
There’s never a shortage of fans complaining about refs on a football Sunday, but what took place between the Panthers and Saints was an utter joke on both sides of the ball. Travel issues led to the NFL promoting a backup crew to call the game, and what ensued was 60 minutes of incorrect calls, wild interpretations of the rules, and flat-out mistakes so bad that it’s left everyone with a bad taste in their mouths.
The big play making the rounds right now was a controversial final drive pass interference call on Kool-Aid McKinstry, which put Carolina in field goal range and allowed them to win as time expired.
McKinstry has said it was a bad call, so did his Saints teammates, and Kellen Moore hinted that the call “went against them,” which is all somewhat fair. This is a very borderline pass interference call, but it also served as a makegood for a similar pass interference call on Carolina the drive prior.
Pass interference has become a mess in the NFL, but these two plays were far from the worst on the day. They came at the most critical moments, but there were some absolutely horrific calls from the officiating crew. Unquestionably the worst came on a phantom 15-yard facemask call, in which the Panthers defender didn’t grab any facemask at all.
The weirdest part of this is that the 15-yard variant of the penalty is reserved for intentionally grabbing the facemask. At no point is even incidental contact made, with the entire tackle coming from the shoulder pads. It’s almost as if the officials saw the ball carrier fall at a weird angle, and called the penalty based on what they assumed had to be from a facemask.
That’s not all folks! How about a horse collar tackle called inside the pocket, where it’s legal?
On the final angle you can see that Tyler Shough was clearly brought down inside the hash marks.
As bad as these individual calls were, the officiating crew decided to become main characters in the game by calling every single ticky-tack call they could find, even when they were woefully wrong. It resulted in a truly disgusting amount of penalties, with players confused why they were getting flagged — and even Fox Sports’ Mike Pereira admitting that the crew was getting a lot of these calls wrong.
Officials called 20 penalties, 17 against the Panthers, for 152 yards. The debacle underscores how unprepared the NFL is when it comes to game officials. At the best of times refereeing is spotty, and at worse — well, we get this.

