Six teams hit the bye in Week 11, forcing fantasy managers to replace reliable legs from the Rams, Seahawks, Packers, Patriots, Falcons and Browns. Rather than chasing big names or top-five rankings, smart managers target hidden volume, dome environments and leaky defenses. The numbers point toward three under-the-radar kickers to start and three recognizable options to bench.

Week 11 Kicker Start ‘Em

New York Jets kicker Jason Sanders (19) celebrates a field goal with Austin McNamara (14) during the fourth quarter at Acrisure Stadium.
Barry Reeger-Imagn Images

Jason Sanders, New York Jets (at LAC)

Ranked outside the top 14 in weekly projections and rostered in just 12 percent of leagues, Sanders quietly ranks second among kickers with 103.0 fantasy points (10.3 per game). He has drilled 25 of 28 field goals (89.3 percent) and 13 of 14 extra points across 10 games, including a 10-for-10 mark from 30 to 39 yards and four makes from 50-plus. He faces a Chargers defense yielding 9.0 fantasy points per game to kickers, second-most in the NFL, allowing 19 field goals on 22 tries.

Joey Slye, Tennessee Titans (at DAL)

Rostered in under one percent of leagues and ranked outside the top 10 this week, Slye gets an ideal indoor matchup at AT&T Stadium. He has converted 15 of 16 field goals (93.8 percent) and all 14 extra points over nine games, hitting four of five tries from 50-plus yards with multiple field goals in three of his past four outings. Facing a Dallas defense allowing 8.2 fantasy points per game to kickers, 31 extra points and a 94.1 percent field goal conversion rate offers huge upside.

Wil Lutz, Denver Broncos (vs. LV)

Available in over 90 percent of leagues and outside the top 10 in consensus rankings, Lutz returns from Denver's bye in thin mountain air. He has made 16 of 19 field goals (84.2 percent) and all 16 extra points across nine contests, topping nine fantasy points in five of his past six appearances. Now he draws a Las Vegas defense surrendering nearly 29 points per game, 31 extra points and 7.8 fantasy points per game to kickers.

Week 11 Kicker Sit ‘Em

© Steven Bisig-Imagn Images

Chase McLaughlin, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (at DET)

Benching the fifth-highest-scoring kicker feels risky, yet the matchup demands it. McLaughlin has totaled 99.0 fantasy points (11.0 per game) behind a spotless 22-for-22 field goal mark and 18-for-18 extra point clip. However, Tampa Bay visits a Detroit defense surrendering an NFL-low 5.0 fantasy points per game to kickers, holding opponents to nine made field goals on 15 attempts (60.0 percent) across nine games.

Article Continues Below

Eddy Pineiro, San Francisco 49ers (vs. MIN)

Rostered in 64 percent of leagues, Pineiro just posted eight points in San Francisco's 46-40 win over Dallas. Do not chase that shootout into Mexico City. The 49ers face a Minnesota defense yielding just 6.0 fantasy points per game to kickers, third-fewest in the NFL, while holding opponents to 15 field goals on 19 tries (78.9 percent) across nine games.

Matt Gay, Las Vegas Raiders (at DEN)

Gay ranks seventh among kickers with 98.0 fantasy points (9.8 per game), hitting 21 of 23 field goals (91.3 percent) and all 22 extra points while rostered in over half of leagues. Still, Las Vegas scored just 13 points against Seattle in Week 10 and faces a 7-2 Denver defense allowing only 20.7 points per game and 7.1 fantasy points per game to kickers.

Winning Week 11 at kicker comes down to chasing volume, indoor tracks and soft defenses over draft-day pedigree. Make these moves now.