Arch Manning entered the 2026 college football season with expectations of becoming the next No. 1 overall NFL Draft pick. However, Texas' star quarterback is conspicuously absent from the first round of ESPN analyst Jordan Reid's latest 2027 mock draft. Instead, four other quarterbacks are projected to hear their names called on Day 1. This reflects Manning's uneven season and the rising stock of several intriguing alternatives.

Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker headlines the group at No. 2. The New York Jets are projected to acquire the pick through a trade with the Los Angeles Chargers. Notre Dame's CJ Carr follows at No. 8 to Atlanta. That's where Reid sees him as a potential successor to Michael Penix Jr. Reid even compares his playing style to a more mobile Kirk Cousins. At No. 17, South Carolina's LaNorris Sellers lands with Cleveland through the Los Angeles Rams' selection. He offers a potential long-term answer beyond Deshaun Watson. Miami's Darian Mensah rounds out the quartet at No. 29. Minnesota potentially views him as a future replacement for Cousins.

Manning's omission is particularly notable given his preseason billing. The 6-foot-4 Texas quarterback has thrown for 2,198 yards and 19 touchdowns through 10 games. He has helped the Longhorns reach an 8–2 record. However, 10 interceptions, mechanical inconsistencies, and struggles under pressure have cooled his draft stock. His impressive arm talent and mobility remain attractive traits. That said, evaluators still have questions about his consistency. Manning has yet to decide whether to enter the 2027 draft or return to Austin. That leaves his eventual draft position uncertain.