Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman was a popular candidate to be moved ahead of the 2026 MLB trade deadline. The Rockies ultimately held onto the two-time All-Star catcher, however. The New York Yankees were among the teams linked to Goodman. It seems as if the chances of a Goodman trade coming to fruition this offseason have increased — although that doesn't mean a deal is guaranteed to happen.

The Rockies are reportedly not against the idea of trading Goodman. According to Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon of The Athletic, Colorado would want a “monster return” in a potential Goodman deal.

Goodman hit 31 home runs in 2025 and 41 in 2026. He recorded an .843 2025 OPS and .839 2026 OPS. The 27-year-old does not always receive the most attention since he plays for an underperforming Rockies ball club, but he's become one of the best offensive catchers in the game.

Article Continues Below

The Yankees, meanwhile, need more offensive production from the catcher position. The idea of Ben Rice catching some games in 2027 has been floated, but he wouldn't be the everyday catcher even in that scenario. Austin Wells struggled a season ago. Acquiring a catcher this offseason could be one of New York's priorities.

The question is whether or not the Yankees would be willing to give up a “monster” return for Goodman. Colorado does not need to rush to move him. He's still under team control for multiple seasons. Given their rebuilding status, though, the Rockies would unquestionably benefit from a massive return for the All-Star catcher sooner rather than later.