LOS ANGELES -- The central focus of the Dodgers' offseason thus far has been how far they will go in pursuit of a reunion with top free agent Tarik Skubal, but another big question could have similarly important implications: How do they approach left field next year?
Under status quo, Teoscar Hernández would remain the starting left fielder in the final guaranteed season of his three-year, $66 million contract, which also includes a club option for 2028. But after top prospect Josue De Paula burst onto the scene with an impressive big league debut at the end of last season, there's a legitimate question of whether it's time for a changing of the guard.
After an unsatisfying end to last season, the Dodgers will look for opportunities to play their prospects next year, in which they'll search to continue their winning ways while keeping their competitive window wide open for the foreseeable future.
Creating meaningful opportunities for young players may require trading off the big league roster, and general manager Brandon Gomes has indicated that the Dodgers will at least consider making such moves.
"I think we feel really good about our team as is, and certainly don't feel compelled to do anything along those lines," Gomes told reporters at last week's General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas. "As far as due diligence, we'll always listen."
Let's go through some of the pros and cons of a potential Hernández trade:
Pro: De Paula has a path to everyday playing time
De Paula, who ranks as MLB Pipeline's No. 4 overall prospect, convinced the Dodgers that his bat plays at the big league level after filling in for an injured Shohei Ohtani in 11 games in September. The 21-year-old went 10-for-31 (.323) and reached base in half of his plate appearances, hardly missing a beat after being promoted directly from Double-A Tulsa. He only played six innings in left field for the Dodgers this past season, but that would be his position if the team believes he is ready to be an everyday player.
Con: De Paula might not be ready to play the field every day
While De Paula impressed with his bat, the Dodgers have made it clear that he needs to work on his defense. The front office was impressed by the strides that he made from 2025 to '26 in the field, and they are hoping that he makes similar progress heading into the '27 season. But what if his glove proves to be a bigger growing pain than expected? Hernández is no slick fielder himself, but he at least has years of experience fielding his position at the big league level. He would be an expensive backup or platoon option, but keeping him around as insurance could make some sense.
Pro: Other teams could have a larger need for Hernández
The free-agent market is not especially flush with right-handed-hitting outfielders this offseason. So even though Hernández would not come cheap -- he's set to earn $14.5 million in 2027, with a $15 million club option or $6.5 million buyout for '28 -- he may be one of the better options for teams seeking players with his qualities. Hernández is set to enter his age-34 season, but he had stretches last year where he showed that he has plenty left in the tank, including hitting .343 with a .980 OPS through his final 27 regular-season games.
Con: Trading Hernández would create a hole in the roster … and the clubhouse
If the Dodgers were to trade Hernández, then they would lose a veteran righty bat on a team that can skew left-handed at times. But while his impact on the lineup is noteworthy, his impact on his teammates may be more important. Hernández is a leader in a L.A. clubhouse that has already lost Miguel Rojas to retirement and Kiké Hernández to free agency this offseason. Preserving team chemistry may be more of an art than a science, but it has to be something the Dodgers weigh carefully as they build out their roster for next season.

