Fantasy football managers spend months preparing for their drafts, only for Week 1 to turn carefully constructed lineups into rubble. Sunday delivered several painful performances from early-round stars, including Drake London, Terry McLaurin and Ja’Marr Chase. One ugly box score should not trigger a panic trade, but usage, health and offensive environment can reveal which bad beats deserve genuine concern.

Drake London & Terry McLaurin usage raises alarms

Atlanta Falcons wide receiver Drake London (5) against the Arizona Cardinals at State Farm Stadium.
Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

London was drafted as a borderline WR1, yet Atlanta treated him like a secondary option in its 20-13 loss to Pittsburgh. He caught two of four targets for 29 yards and added six yards on one rushing attempt, producing just 5.5 PPR points. The four targets matter far more than the modest yardage. London commanded a 30.3% target share over the first 10 weeks of 2025, so managers expected Atlanta’s passing game to continue flowing through him even with QB3 Cooper Rush under center.

The Falcons’ offense never established rhythm, and London cannot create WR1 production if the weekly passing volume remains low and his target share collapses. He is too talented to bench, but this is a situation to monitor closely in Week 2. Another game with four or five opportunities would move London from “unlucky” to “potentially overvalued.”

McLaurin’s disappointment was even more severe. Washington’s veteran receiver caught two of four targets for only 14 yards against Philadelphia after entering the week as a popular WR2. Stefon Diggs’ arrival gave Jayden Daniels another established option, and McLaurin’s limited volume suggests his weekly floor may be lower than anticipated.

Across 22 matchups with #Eagles corners Riq Woolen and Quinyon Mitchell, Terry McLaurin finished with 0 catches on 1 target, per @NextGenStats. pic.twitter.com/S7agtU0xEc

— Devin Jackson (@RealD_Jackson) September 14, 2026

The matchup with Philadelphia was difficult, and Washington’s offense struggled with consistency throughout its 24-22 loss. Managers should still start McLaurin in favorable spots, but he may be more touchdown-dependent than in previous seasons. Unlike London, he was not drafted to dominate targets, making his path back to reliable production less certain.

Elite players that deserve patience

Chase delivered the biggest first-round gut punch, catching two of four targets for 12 yards in Cincinnati’s 33-27 victory over Tampa Bay. He finished behind Mike Gesicki, Tee Higgins and Chase Brown in targets despite Joe Burrow throwing for 254 yards. That is a nightmare outcome for managers who selected Chase as an anchor.

This is not the time to sell. Chase remains an elite separator tied to an elite quarterback, and Cincinnati scored 33 points without needing to force-feed him. Defenses will build game plans around removing Chase, but four targets should prove to be an outlier rather than a new baseline. If an anxious manager is willing to discount him, Chase is a clear buy-low candidate.

Ja'Marr Chase fantasy points scored in Week 1 over the last 4 years:

2023: 6.6
2024: 9.2
2025: 3.6
2026: 2.2 pic.twitter.com/wM8OhKOh1A

— Yahoo Fantasy Sports (@YahooFantasy) September 14, 2026

Article Continues Below

Christian McCaffrey also fell short of his premium price, totaling 68 rushing yards and 20 receiving yards without a touchdown in San Francisco’s 27-7 win over the Rams. His 15 touches were disappointing, but the 49ers controlled the game, and McCaffrey averaged 6.8 yards per carry. Efficiency and receiving involvement remain intact, so concern should be minimal unless the reduced workload continues.

George Kittle produced only two catches for 12 yards on five targets in his return from an Achilles injury. That stat line was painful at a thin position, but San Francisco had indicated it could monitor his workload. Simply playing in Week 1 represented progress, and five targets provide some encouragement.

Saquon Barkley was another frustrating non-scorer, finishing with 83 rushing yards and -3 receiving yards on one catch. His 42-yard run salvaged the day, but 16 touches and no goal-line payoff fell short of RB1 expectations. Still, Philadelphia won, Barkley averaged 5.5 yards per carry and the workload remained clearly his.

London and McLaurin are the names to watch because their problems involved opportunity rather than efficiency. Chase, McCaffrey, Kittle and Barkley burned managers, but their roles and talent remain strong enough to demand patience. Week 1 should shape expectations—not dictate emotional roster moves.