The New York Yankees are looking to address a number of different areas of their roster. David Bednar accepted his qualifying offer which removes some pressure of adding to the bullpen, but they will still surely attempt to add a reliever or two. Upgrading the third base position is rumored to be a priority as well. Catcher is another area of the roster that New York is expected to address.

How will the Yankees approach their strategy to adding a catcher, however? While they could look to trade for a star such as the Colorado Rockies' Hunter Goodman, signing a free agent like Carson Kelly also presents an option.

Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic recently referred to Kelly as the “perfect right-handed alternative” for New York given current catcher Austin Wells' left-handed hitting prowess. Rosenthal also asked the question of whether or not Kelly would be open to a platoon situation. The idea of Kelly finding an everyday job elsewhere is not out of the question.

Article Continues Below

The 32-year-old hit .258 with a .713 OPS in 2026. He's not a star, but Kelly is a veteran catcher who made his big league debut back in 2016. He hits well enough for the position and also understands what it requires to help manage a pitching staff.

The fit with the Yankees would make sense, but Kelly is likely going to consider all of his options before agreeing to a platoon role. Whether it is by adding Kelly or someone else, the Yankees are seemingly hoping to upgrade the catcher position this offseason.