The New York Yankees have two starters under club control beyond 2027 in Will Warren and Ryan Weathers. A new free-agent deal offers a benchmark for what that rotation depth might be worth.
The Chicago White Sox announced a three-year, $52.5 million deal with Dustin May on Wednesday. The contract averages $17.5 million per season.
That price provides context for a potential offseason decision facing the Yankees if they consider trading Warren or Weathers. In an article written by The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal, he pointed to May’s deal as a benchmark for what New York might receive in return for either starting pitcher.
“If $17.5 million per season is the price for such modestly accomplished pitching, then what might the New York Yankees get in a trade for a controllable starter such as right-hander Will Warren or lefty Ryan Weathers?”
At the general managers’ meetings, Yankees general manager Brian Cashman addressed whether he would consider trading young pitching this offseason.
“That might be something I have to consider based on all the information grabs we are taking from these meetings and beyond. I’d rather our pitching stay intact if I can help it.”
Rosenthal also pointed out that Cashman had fielded interest from other clubs in New York’s pitching both this offseason and last summer.
Article Continues Below“I’ve already received countless amount of interest in our pitching, and I did last summer too.”
Rosenthal expects Warren, 27, to earn near the league minimum in 2027 and projects Weathers, 26, to earn about $3 million in his second year of arbitration. The Yankees have four more seasons of club control over Warren and two over Weathers.
Cashman described interest in the Yankees’ pitching staff generally. Warren and Weathers were Rosenthal’s examples of how the club could use its rotation depth to address another roster need. The question for New York is what kind of return would justify giving up an affordable starter it could keep for multiple seasons.

