The New York Yankees should offer Alec Bohm one year and $14 million guaranteed for 2027. With limited appealing options at third base, they can justify paying a premium for a right-handed hitter without guaranteeing multiple seasons.

The proposed contract would include no options, opt-outs or incentives. This is an editorial recommendation, not a reported offer or asking price. Its purpose is to improve a vulnerable position while limiting how long the Yankees carry the risk.

Bohm’s recovery supports a measured bet

Bohm’s 2026 numbers require looking beyond either his disappointing start or encouraging finish. The 30-year-old hit .249/.315/.383 with 15 home runs and 88 RBI across 155 games for the Philadelphia Phillies.

Those numbers do not describe an obvious offensive centerpiece. They also obscure the improvement that followed his early struggles.

From May 9 through the end of the season, Bohm hit .274/.340/.433 with 14 home runs in 120 games. His second-half OPS reached .794.

That recovery supports expecting more than his full-season line suggests, but it does not establish that his next season will resemble his best stretch. New York should pay for the possibility of improvement without treating it as certain.

The stronger argument involves left-handed pitching. Bohm hit .292/.333/.483 against lefties in 192 plate appearances, producing seven home runs and an .816 OPS.

That is a specific offensive strength the Yankees can use. His consecutive 97-RBI seasons in 2023 and 2024 demonstrate experience contributing in a productive lineup, although RBI totals alone do not establish his value.

Yankees third base needs another offensive option

Ryan McMahon hit .213/.279/.357 with 11 home runs and 41 RBI in 124 games in 2026. Returning the same personnel without another credible option would leave the Yankees depending heavily on internal improvement.

McMahon also has one year and $16 million remaining on his contract. Adding Bohm would increase the investment at the position without automatically removing that existing obligation.

Bohm would give the Yankees a right-handed alternative against left-handers. That makes a platoon with McMahon a reasonable starting framework, rather than evidence that either player must immediately disappear from the roster.

However, a $14 million guarantee requires more thought than simply identifying a favorable matchup. New York must explain how Bohm can earn additional opportunities if he hits.

His defensive limitations complicate that discussion. Playing third base regularly would require balancing the offensive improvement against the runs his glove could surrender.

First-base experience provides flexibility, but Ben Rice and Luis Garcia Jr. already create competition there. Designated-hitter opportunities also cannot be treated as unlimited.

The Yankees should establish the role before making the commitment. Bohm needs a meaningful chance to contribute, and the club needs a plan that justifies paying more than a narrow platoon assignment warrants.

Why one year and $14 million balances the risk

Article Continues Below

The Yankees should treat $14 million as their limit for a one-year agreement, with the offer contingent on a credible plan for meaningful playing time. Paying that amount for occasional starts against left-handers would weaken the case.

The case for paying a premium is securing a useful right-handed bat without adding another guaranteed season. That trade-off works only if the Yankees expect enough playing time to justify the higher annual investment.

The commitment could make New York’s offer more attractive without guaranteeing salary beyond 2027. Bohm would receive financial security for one season while retaining the opportunity to seek a longer contract after a rebound.

Another club could offer more years or a clearer everyday role. The Yankees should accept that possibility rather than stretch their proposal beyond what his production and their roster justify.

The salary would remain guaranteed if Bohm struggles. A one-year deal limits the duration of that risk, while the absence of a qualifying offer eliminates the associated draft-pick penalty.

The Yankees have already met with Bohm’s representatives. Their next step should be to establish how he fits alongside McMahon and the other corner-infield options. If they can provide enough opportunities to justify the investment, one year and $14 million is a defensible offer. If they cannot, they should spend elsewhere.