Hello, MLB world. We've heard it all at this point.

MLB has claimed a salary cap and floor will help to address local blackouts. The MLBPA has claimed the salary cap/floor idea will “strip fundamental rights from players.” MLB commissioner Rob Manfred recently made it clear that the league isn't willing to compromise on the salary cap conversation. Both sides continue to publicly air their grievances in hopes of winning the public over. While it's difficult to truly embrace either side in this millionaires vs. billionaires financial battle, the MLBPA continues to miss the point in their public announcements.

MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer released a statement on Wednesday following Manfred's claim about MLB being unwilling to compromise on the salary cap/floor discussion. We will take a look at Meyer's quote and then break down the error in the MLBPA's approach to the situation.

“There can be no clearer example of the league’s lack of seriousness than their insistence that they will not negotiate over the economics outside of a radical change to the system that would dramatically reduce overall player compensation for all categories of players and strip fundamental rights from players like the ability to have truly guaranteed contracts,” Meyer said. “There should be no illusions about the owners’ true motivation in pushing for this system. They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries.”

The MLBPA is seemingly hoping for fans to empathize with them in their grievances against the owners. The reality of the situation is the common baseball fan doesn't care how much money the owners make. All the fans want — aside from potentially the Los Angeles Dodgers faithful right now given their juggernaut of a roster — is for there to be a level playing field.

Let's break it down even more

Perhaps deep down the players believe they have the fans' best interest at heart. It sure doesn't seem that way, though. Rather, the MLBPA has an obsession with trying to make the point that the owners are greedy and that's why a salary cap is bad.

Are owners partially to blame for the mess that has become the Major League Baseball competitive fairness landscape? Sure. If small-market owners reached deeper into their pockets then things may be different. With that being said, many small-market teams simply don't have the same appeal of a big market and can't offer as much money to players in the current landscape of the league.

Now, when it comes to the MLBPA's stance, current free agent pitcher Jameson Taillon shared his take on a video MLB recently posted about their side of the argument. Taillon's post on X, formerly Twitter, perfectly exemplifies the point of the players putting their angst against the owners ahead of being content with making millions while playing a kid's game.

“This is comically bad,” Taillon wrote. “They’re being very careful and selective of what they’re saying/showing and how they’re delivering it. This is going to be ugly if they’re trying to sway fan/public support weeks before they even lock us out. At the end of the day- they want to drive down salaries and put more money in the pockets of billionaires. Nobody wins except them. Simple as that. It’s not about competition. It’s never been about competition for them, it just is a nice cover up.”

Taillon writes that “nobody wins except them.” Is that true, though?

Why a salary cap/floor benefits fans

A salary cap and floor would force small-market teams to spend more while limiting big-market teams — such as the Dodgers — from signing every single superstar known to man (when it comes to the Dodgers, this is pretty much only a partial joke at this point).

Imagine fans of the Pittsburgh Pirates, for example, actually feeling like their favorite team could make a push for top free agent Tarik Skubal? Or the Cleveland Guardians, Kansas City Royals, etc. Imagine if the MLB rumor mill didn't link the same four-six teams to the star free agents every single year?

Article Continues Below

That's what MLB fans want, and I'd say that is far from everyone losing.

So again, I'll say the quiet part out loud and I hope the MLBPA and players everywhere are paying attention: Most baseball fans don't care about your grievances with the owners. They simply want a level playing field.

Fans aren't dumb. While the average person isn't making anywhere near one million dollars, they know millionaire baseball players will be fine even with a salary cap and floor implemented. And if it benefits billionaire owners then so be it.

You hear players after almost every win thank the fans for their support. They'll say they love the city they play in and they want to win for the fans. Yet, as things stand right now, one has to wonder if that is true. If the players truly want the best for the fans, then they will swallow their pride, continue to make more money than the average person can ever dream of, and accept a new CBA as soon as possible to avoid the expected lockout impacting the season.

The MLBPA is welcome to continue fighting against the salary cap and floor, but they need to choose a different angle. Their current approach is forcing many baseball fans to side with owners and MLB itself.