A list of who should feel good and who will need a miracle to get in.

TUCSON, ARIZONA - NOVEMBER 14: (Photo by Patrick Mulligan/Getty Images)
Getty Images

Three weeks until Selection Sunday, and the College Football Playoff race is starting to look — dare I say it — clear?

Entering Week 11, I counted 32 teams with a nonzero shot at making the 12-team bracket.

After Ole Miss bowed out of contention with a Sunday loss to Oklahoma, we’re down to 23 of those teams, but even that number is as generous as possible. With two games plus conference championships to go, the number of sincere contenders for a spot is about 15.

The playoff selection committee unveils its third batch of rankings on Tuesday night. Rather than slot teams into a bracket that will change or a ranking list that won’t be exactly right, I suggest you think about the playoff race in the context of tiers. Here’s where all of these teams stand.

PROBABLY ALREADY IN

Utah (10-0)

The Utes are the first team in the country to have, in my opinion, clinched a spot. Even in the shocking event of this team taking back-to-back losses to TCU and West Virginia and then losing the Big 12 Championship, I don’t think the selection committee would send Utah (currently ranked No. 2) all the way out of the field. The Utes would still be a 10-win team that passes “the eye test” with a Heisman Trophy candidate QB in Devon Dampier. They’d still have an excellent win over BYU. They may even have additional ranked wins over Houston and Arizona, depending on where those teams settle.

IN BARRING DISASTER

Georgia (9-1)

Alabama (8-2)

Notre Dame (9-1)

UCLA (10-0)

Texas (8-2)

Miami (9-1)

These teams would need to lose multiple games in order to not make the field. The committee adores Bama and would take the Tide even with an Iron Bowl loss to a respectable Auburn. Texas is going to end up with five or six ranked wins and would also have no problem as a three-loss team. SEC-leading UGA would need to go down to both South Carolina and Georgia Tech, which, well, fat chance. Notre Dame’s No. 5 ranking last Tuesday suggests to me that even a loss to a middling SMU team this week would not knock out the Irish; they’d then have to lose another game at Syracuse. The same is true for Miami, which would have to lose to both Virginia Tech and Boston College, each at home.

The trickiest team to place here is UCLA. Are the Bruins already locked in at 10-0? Probably not, despite the now-very-high odds Bob Chesney’s team makes the field. Their last two games are against Michigan (a miserable offense but a good defense that could ensure a 14-10 style of game) and USC (a deeply flawed team that still has a better offense than UCLA’s). If the Bruins lost both of those, they could still make the Big Ten Championship. But to be absolutely certain of entry, UCLA should win one more. That’s the price of having exactly one notable win, which came at Oregon back in Week 6.

IN VERY GOOD POSITION

Indiana (9-1)

Texas Tech (9-1)

Hoosier fans will feel aggrieved not to be in a higher tier, and I get it. But there’s a non-outrageous scenario in which the Hoosiers have a tense Selection Sunday: If Indiana lost to Washington next week as a roughly 8-point favorite, they’d be likelier than not to miss the Big Ten Championship in favor of Ohio State or Oregon. In no world will the Hoosiers also lose to Purdue on Thanksgiving weekend, but a 10-2 Indiana might find itself in a mosh pit that also includes 10-2 BYU and 10-2 Iowa. The Hoosiers would be above the Hawkeyes in that case, I suspect, but would fall behind the Cougars, who beat Notre Dame.

CONTROLLING THEIR FATE, BUT SWEATING

Tennessee (8-2)

Wake Forest (9-1)

Tennessee makes the field, no questions asked, by winning its last two games against LSU and Vanderbilt. LSU may or may not even care about that game, and Vanderbilt is bad. But the Tigers are still talented, and no Tennessee fan will think that game is a cakewalk.

Wake is fresh off one of the most dominant efforts of the season, a romp at SMU that saw the Deacs take a 42-point lead by halftime. Closing out the regular season with wins over Georgia Tech and Duke would put Wake in the ACC Championship against Miami. What would happen if Wake lost that game, dropping to 11-2 and with both losses coming against Miami? The committee might treat the Deacs the same way it treated 11-2 BYU, which had two losses to Texas Tech, a year ago. (BYU just missed the bracket.)

On the other hand, Wake’s win over Louisville in Week 4 could soon become very helpful. The Cardinals have won five in a row and should count as a ranked win for Wake as soon as Tuesday night.

CONTESTED BORDER AREA

BYU (8-2)

Iowa (8-2)

Oregon (7-3)

If all 11 of the teams in the previous tiers handle their business, all three of these teams are out. But someone is not going to handle business, opening up a path for one of these bubble teams. If everyone here wins out, this is how they’d stack up:

  • 10-2 BYU, with a premium win over Notre Dame but maybe no other top-25 wins (depending on whether 7-3 Arizona winds up in the top 25)
  • 10-2 Iowa, with the imprimatur of being a Big Ten team but a “best win” over, uh, Nebraska? Or Northwestern? Or Iowa State? Or Michigan?
  • 9-3 Oregon, with likely or potential ranked wins over Boise State, USC, and Ohio State

The committee ranked BYU 10th, Iowa 15th, and Oregon 16th this week. BYU would come out ahead in any comparison of these teams, but what would the committee do with Iowa and Oregon?

THE GROUP OF 6 RACE

Boise State (9-1)

Louisiana Tech (8-2)

Liberty (9-1)

Memphis (8-2)

UTSA (8-2)

Goodbye to the New Mexico Lobos, who gave up two massive touchdowns to UNLV reclamation project Jackson Arnold in the fourth quarter on Saturday night to bow out of this race. UNM was probably the No. 2 Group of 6 team behind Boise State. (I say probably because the committee doesn’t tell us how it ranks any G6 teams who are outside the overall top 25.) With the Lobos out of the way, it’s possible Boise has more than one loss’s worth of margin for error. Nobody on this list has a ranked or even power-conference win, so I’m doing a ton of guesswork about the order that comes after the Broncos.

THREE-LOSS MIRACLE REQUIRED

Ohio State (7-3)

Louisville (7-3)

USC (7-3)

Kentucky (7-3)

Ohio State and Louisville still have non-absurd paths to their conference championship games, at which point they’d be win-and-in. One path for Ohio State is to win out, have Indiana lose at Washington, and get chalk across the rest of the Big Ten. Louisville could get there by beating Pitt and having Wake Forest lose to both Georgia Tech and Duke. These would qualify as miracles.

USC and Kentucky are what I would call “eliminated for all intents and purposes,” but I’m chickening out and not declaring them all the way dead until a few more things get locked in above them. I think there’s a sequence of events that could bring one of them back into play, but it would take a lot.

NEWLY ELIMINATED

LSU (6-4)

SMU (7-3)

New Mexico (8-2)

North Texas (7-3)

South Carolina (6-4)

Houston (7-3)

Duke (7-3)

Arizona (7-3)

Ole Miss (6-4)

Rest in power to all of these teams. They had good runs and will be fun to watch in their bowl games. Actually, LSU will not be fun to watch in its bowl game. But nevertheless, we will watch.

All of your communities in one place.