Ryan Jeffers chose to return to the Minnesota Twins by accepting the qualifying offer worth $23.15 million — bypassing the opportunity to hear offers from other teams on the open market. Jeffers, who's coming off a 2.6 fWAR season, was expected to sign a multi-year deal in free agency for longer-term security, but he chose to bet on himself in the end.

One of the teams that were expected to be in the running for Jeffers had he elected to hit free agency was the New York Yankees. The Yankees have long been rumored to be in the market for a catcher, and Jeffers' right-handed bat would have given them the platoon partner that incumbent backstop Austin Wells needed.

However, according to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, the cost of signing Jeffers would have been prohibitive for the Yankees. For starters, the Twins' decision to tender him a qualifying offer meant that they were going to give up two picks and international bonus pool space to sign the 29-year-old catcher in addition to whatever it would cost to get him to put pen on paper.

The open market, as Rosenthal explained, also isn't very kind towards catchers. The highest average annual value any free-agent catcher has signed for is $23.1 million, when JT Realmuto signed a five-year, $115.5 million contract with the Philadelphia Phillies. All of the biggest contracts for a catcher in MLB history have come via extension.

Jeffers may not have long-term financial security, but as a catcher with solid pop (he had 14 home runs and 56 runs batted in last season), he should always have a market — provided that he keeps on producing.

Article Continues Below

The Yankees would have been a good fit for Jeffers, but Rosenthal projected that he'll be on the wrong side of the platoon in the Bronx anyway, complicating any pursuit of the 29-year-old.

At the very least, Jeffers can try again in free agency next year, and if he produces the way he did in 2026, he'll be in line to sign a multi-year deal.