As the MLB hot stove thaws, teams across the league continue to search for ways to improve their rosters. Following a surprising 2026 turnaround where they returned to the playoffs, the Chicago White Sox have a few holes to address. Most notably, in the starting rotation. On Tuesday, the White Sox signed starting pitcher Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract to join the starting staff. While many think May's career numbers don't warrant such a big deal, MLB insider Ken Rosenthal believes differently. MLB show Foul Territory shared Rosenthal's analysis via X, formerly Twitter.

You could argue that Dustin May's career numbers don't merit $52.5M, but that's not always how teams look at it, @Ken_Rosenthal explains…

"This is a deal based on underlying and advanced metrics. Things that the people who run teams say are under-the-hood measures." pic.twitter.com/rdPabU7kb8

— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) November 17, 2026

“This is a deal based on underlying and advanced metrics,” Rosenthal described on the show. “Things that the people who run teams say are under-the-hood measures.”

Article Continues Below

Since coming up through the Los Angeles Dodgers' system as a top prospect, May has bounced around a bit. May has pitched for the Boston Red Sox, St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers over the last two seasons, including time with the Dodgers. Now, the 29-year-old looks to become a dependable mid-rotation piece with the White Sox.

Despite his middling numbers, May has shown plenty of dominant flashes throughout his career. The problem has been mostly injury-related, as May has spent multiple stints on the IL. The ex-Brewer still possesses strong stuff and could be a good fit for the White Sox. Clearly, the advanced and underlying metrics convinced Chicago to add May to a rotation that already features young arms like Sean Burke and Grant Taylor. Can May help lead an emerging staff deeper into October next fall? Or will his contract end up being a bust, like many claim it already is?