Yordan Alvarez has looked like a lock for American League MVP for most of September, sitting at .310 with 38 home runs, 96 RBIs and a 1.016 OPS. But at least one prominent voice believes the award belongs in Tampa Bay instead.

MLB Network's Jim Bowden made the case for Rays third baseman Junior Caminero over Alvarez, arguing that Tampa Bay's playoff push simply doesn't happen without him. “Take Caminero off the Rays, and the Yankees win the division. I don't even know if Houston gets in,” Bowden said, adding, “The Rays wouldn't be here without Caminero.”

Article Continues Below

The numbers back up part of that argument. Caminero is hitting .279 with 40 home runs, 95 RBIs and an .896 OPS, and he's been the engine behind Tampa Bay's surprising run to the top of the AL East. The Rays sit at 90-59, holding a comfortable division lead over the Yankees and have already clinched a postseason berth for the first time since 2023.

Bowden's value-over-raw-stats framing is exactly the kind of argument that fuels MVP debates every September. Alvarez remains the individual statistical leader and the betting favorite, with some sportsbooks pricing him as high as a 99% favorite to win the award. Caminero, meanwhile, has been described by others as the biggest producer amid the Rays' first-place push, with a career-best walk rate and a shot at back-to-back 40-homer seasons.

For Astros fans, the debate carries extra weight. Houston's own playoff positioning has wavered, and Bowden's comment suggesting the Astros might not even make the postseason without Caminero's absence from Tampa Bay's lineup underscores how tightly the AL race has been contested. Whether or not Caminero pulls off the upset, the argument shows just how much the Rays' season has been defined by one player's breakout year.