If the ball is reverse swinging, as a bowler I'll know straight away, says Irfan Pathan

The former India pacer shared his perspective on ball tampering detection during JioStar's Sandpapergate debate, citing his Duleep Trophy experience and addressing the ongoing controversy.

Former India pacer Irfan Pathan has offered his perspective on whether bowlers can detect ball tampering when reverse swing develops during a match.

Pathan's analysis centres on the conditions under which reverse swing occurs and the visibility of ball tampering to players on the field. He cited the Rajkot Duleep Trophy match as an example of natural reverse swing, where the dry pitch conditions without grass cover allowed the ball to move in reverse around the eighth or tenth over without any deliberate interference.

"It's not possible that, if the ball is reverse swinging and as a bowler, I won't know if something has been done to the ball. I'll know straight away. In my career, the only time I didn't know the ball was reverse swinging was in Rajkot during the Duleep Trophy, because the conditions were so dry. It started reverse swinging around the eighth or 10th over. There was no grass on the ground, and the pitch was extremely dry, so reverse swing happened naturally. But if you put something on the ball around the 30th or 40th over, when its colour has changed, you will know as a bowler. The entire team knows what's happening with the ball at any given time," Pathan said on JioStar.

Why does Pathan sympathise with Cameron Bancroft?

Pathan expressed deep sympathy for Cameron Bancroft, the young Australian batter who faced the heaviest consequences of the Sandpapergate scandal. Bancroft served a nine-month ban and played only two Test matches after his suspension ended, a stark contrast to the career trajectories of his senior teammates implicated in the same incident.

"I really feel bad for Cameron Bancroft because he lost everything. He played only two Test matches after serving a nine-month ban. It's always the youngsters, the weaker ones, who get punished the most. Warner came back and played quite a few games. Even Steve Smith, who was stripped of the captaincy, got to lead the side again in Pat Cummins' absence. But what about the youngster? No one is talking about Bancroft, who took the hit," Pathan said.

Should Sandpapergate be reopened?

Pathan acknowledged that reopening the Sandpapergate matter eight years after the incident raises questions about timing and purpose. Cricket Australia had completed a four-day investigation into the affair, which concluded the official inquiry into what occurred during the 2018 Test in South Africa. However, Pathan recognised that Usman Khawaja's right to document his account in his autobiography reflects a broader desire for clarity on the incident.

"The question is, should we be talking about it right now? I think it's way past that. What has happened, happened. There was a four-day investigation by Cricket Australia, and it was done and dusted. I understand Usman Khawaja's point of view because everyone deserves to write their book. You might question why he is bringing up these stories right now, but what else will he do? I also totally understand what Pat Cummins is trying to say as well. But if something has happened, and if Australian media and people want answers, then the investigation should start again," Pathan concluded.