The New York Giants are in first place in the NFC East, and that's a shocking development considering the team has failed to make the playoffs in eight of the last nine years and finished last in the division four times in that span.
However, even though they are playing in one of the worst divisions in the NFL, nothing is secure for John Harbaugh's team. The Giants are coming off a brutal home loss to the Washington Commanders, and that's an indication that the team is simply not mature enough to win key games.
The Giants don't know how to win when the game is on the line. If they get off to a good start, the Giants can ride that wave. However, if they get involved in a close game in the fourth quarter, the Giants don't have the on-field leadership to get the job done.
That's not a surprise because they have recently acquired J.J. McCarthy at quarterback. The former national champion from Michigan and first-round draft choice of the Minnesota Vikings has already had a few highlight-film moments for the Giants but he has not demonstrated the consistency needed to win.
It's a similar conclusion on running back Cam Skattebo. He is certainly an entertaining runner and very much a crowd pleaser. When he gets through the line of scrimmage, he is capable of making big plays with his ability to run over defenders.
Skattebo has 116 carries for 496 yards, a 4.3 yards per carry average and 4 TDs. These figures are all workable, but the Giants should have made a big move at the trade deadline for Jonathan Taylor of the Indianapolis Colts.
Taylor is at a completely different level than Skattebo.
Taylor would have been a dynamic move for Harbaugh

The Giants have an ordinary offense at this point even though they have a pair of dynamic pass catchers. Malik Nabers is a game-changing wideout who has been targeted 85 times by Giants quarterbacks and he has caught 58 passes for 692 yards and 2 TDs.
They also have tight end Isaiah Likely, and he is an outstanding red zone and third-down weapon. Likely has caught 55 of 81 targets for 575 yards and 7 touchdowns. He has converted 30 of his receptions into first downs.
However, if the Giants are going to take advantage of the talent they have at the receiver position, they need more consistency from the ground game and that's why acquiring Taylor would have been a sensational move.
Even though the Colts don't appear to be going anywhere this season, Taylor has rushed for 739 yards with 7 TDs and is averaging 4.2 yards per carry.
He rushed for 1,585 yards and 18 touchdowns a year ago, and he can be a big-play machine. More than that, he is dependable any time is offensive line gives him a small hole to get through. The acquisition of Taylor would have raised the level of the Giants offensive scheme.
Key addition to the running game would have helped McCarthy grow
It certainly would have made life easier for McCarthy, who is still being force-fed when it comes to learning the Giants offense.
McCarthy is the third quarterback to take snaps for the Giants this season. This season was supposed to belong to Jaxson Dart, but an injury in Week 2 ended his season. The Giants were forced to play Jameis Winston after the Dart injury, and he made too many mistakes when the game is on the line.
McCarthy has provided a spark, and he has completed 66 of 104 passes in a Giants uniform for 915 yards with 2 TDs and 2 interceptions. It may take McCarthy some time to read defenses consistently, and that's why a top running back like Taylor would have provided a major benefit. Without Taylor, McCarthy will undoubtedly take some knocks to be successful.
Giants also needed help at defensive tackle
The Giants moved quickly when they traded for McCarthy, basically stealing him for a fifth-round draft choice. However, the Giants needed help on the defensive line — particularly at the defensive tackle position — and general manager Joe Schoen did not make a deal.
The Giants were interested in Jeffery Simmons, the huge defensive tackle from the Tennessee Titans who was traded to the Chicago Bears. The Bears realized Simmons is a game-changing player who provided a significant upgrade to their defense and Ryan Poles did not hesitate to make the move.
The Giants also had an interest in Vita Vea of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Tampa Bay was slumping and they are still struggling at 3-6, but they are just one game behind Carolina Panthers (4-5) in the NFC South. However, Vea is one of the best defensive tackles in the NFL and he would cost any team that pursues him a premium package in return that includes a first-round draft choice.
The Giants needed help on the defensive interior, and they were unable to make the move and it will limit them in the second half of the season.

