Eli Manning has been part of some of the most unforgettable moments in NFL history, leading the New York Giants to two Super Bowl championships over Tom Brady and the New England Patriots, including helping deliver one of the greatest upsets the sport has ever seen in Super Bowl 42.

As the Giants' starting quarterback from 2004-19, Manning holds Big Blue's franchise records for passing yards, passing touchdowns, and completions. Never missing a game due to injury, he started 210 consecutive games from 2004 to 2017, the third-longest consecutive starts streak by an NFL quarterback, behind just Brett Favre (297) and Philip Rivers (243).

He also comes from one of the most well-known families in football history. The Mannings have built one of football's greatest legacies. Archie Manning was a 2x Pro Bowler in the NFL with the New Orleans Saints before his sons Peyton and Eli combined for four Super Bowl titles, three Super Bowl MVPs, and five MVP awards. Now, the next generation is carrying on the tradition as Arch Manning, Cooper Manning's son (Peyton and Eli's older brother), leads the Texas Longhorns as quarterback.

Now, the two-time Super Bowl MVP is helping shine a spotlight on a different kind of football history.

Manning recently joined Robin Roberts as an executive producer of Panther Pat, a short documentary telling the remarkable story of Patricia Palinkas, the first woman to play professional football. The project revisits Palinkas' groundbreaking journey with the Orlando Panthers in 1970, a story Manning believes deserves to be remembered and celebrated.

In an exclusive with ClutchPoints, Rob Lepelstat spoke with Manning at the Paley Center for Media in New York City, where he discussed what attracted him to the documentary, reflected on winning two Super Bowls against Brady, head coach Bill Belichick, and the Patriots dynasty, and revisited David Tyree's legendary helmet catch.

Eli Manning explains why he joined the ‘Panther Pat' documentary

Despite being a football historian who has spent decades around the game, Manning admitted that Palinkas' story was one he had never encountered before.

For the former Giants quarterback, discovering that a woman had played professional football 50 years ago was enough to immediately pique his interest.

“I think it's just such a unique story that I had never heard of,” Manning told ClutchPoints. “The fact that I'm such a historian of football and you think you know all the stories, and to say that 50 years ago, there was a lady playing professional football, you're like, nah, I've never heard this.”

Manning explained that the documentary's storytelling and the opportunity to help bring Palinkas' accomplishment back into the spotlight made him excited to get involved.

“I just love the story. And so I was really excited to be about Panther Pat and get to make sure that this story is known and people are — you know, it's not forgotten about. And, you know, she's celebrated for what she was able to accomplish.”

While Manning acknowledged that the creative team, including director Ashley Brandon and Denni Hohne, handled the heavy lifting behind the documentary, he was eager to help promote the project and introduce Palinkas' story to a wider audience.

He also pointed to the unique circumstances that led to Palinkas becoming part of professional football in the first place.

“It's the story of how it all started, just kind of helping out her husband live his dream to become a kicker and her being the holder and just getting invited to kind of go along the ride and her being willing to do it,” Manning explained.

When asked what he hopes audiences take away from the documentary, Manning emphasized that opportunities can come from unexpected places.

Dennis Höhne (Cinematographer and Producer, Panther Pat), Stephanie Palinkas (Pat Palinkas’ daughter), Ashley Brandon (Director, Panther Pat), Suzannah Palinkas (Pat Palinkas' daughter) and two-time Super Bowl champion Eli Manning, who moderated the post-screening conversation.
Dennis Höhne, Stephanie Palinkas, Ashley Brandon, Suzannah Palinkas, and Eli Manning

“Anything's possible,” Manning said. “This is something she, you know, it wasn't necessarily her goal to be a professional football player, but she had the opportunity. She did it. She tried it. And then, you know, hey, she wanted to start a family. That was more important. She went a totally different route, and it didn't define her. But just really that anything's possible and just a fun story to tell.”

More info on the event and the documentary can be seen here: https://www.paleycenter.org/events/paleylive-panther-pat

Eli Manning reflects on winning 2 Super Bowls against Tom Brady

While Panther Pat gave Manning an opportunity to celebrate an important piece of football history, his own legacy with the New York Giants remains unforgettable.

Manning spent 16 seasons with the franchise, capturing two Super Bowl championships and earning MVP honors in both victories.

Both championships came against Brady and the Patriots, making the Giants' victories even more memorable given New England's dominance during that era.

The first came in Super Bowl XLII, when the Giants stunned the previously undefeated Patriots, denying Brady and company a perfect 19-0 season. Four years later, Manning and the Giants did it again, defeating New England in Super Bowl XLVI.

Looking back on those accomplishments, Manning credited the players and coaches around him for coming together at the right time.

“We had great teams, great players, great coaches, and we all put it together at the right time,” Manning told ClutchPoints. “So it's just something special when a team, you know, comes together, they're playing their best football at the end of the season.”

Despite entering the first Super Bowl as significant underdogs, Manning said the Giants never lost belief in what they could accomplish.

“Even though, hey, we were underdogs, and no one gave us a chance, especially in that first one, that we believed and, and, and we, you know, we prepared, we worked hard, and we were able to make it happen.”

Those two championships remain defining moments in sports history, with Manning's performances against one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time helping establish his place as New York sports royalty and among the franchise's all-time greats.

Manning on David Tyree's legendary Helmet Catch

Of course, no conversation about Manning's first Super Bowl victory would be complete without revisiting one of the most iconic plays in NFL history.

With the Giants trailing the Patriots 14-10 with under 90 seconds left in the fourth quarter of Super Bowl XLII, Manning escaped New England's pass rush (and defensive end Jarvis Green grabbing his outstretched jersey from behind) before launching a deep pass downfield to David Tyree.

Tyree, who was being covered by Patriots safety Rodney Harrison, somehow secured the football against his helmet for an incredible 32-yard reception.

The play kept the Giants' championship hopes alive and set up Manning's eventual game-winning touchdown pass to Plaxico Burress.

It’s a special day for the duo that brought us The Helmet Catch.

Happy birthday to both @EliManning & David Tyree! 🥳 pic.twitter.com/d5td4bhRHD

— NFL Legacy (@NFLLegacy) January 3, 2022

Nearly two decades later, the helmet catch remains one of the defining moments of Manning's career.

When asked to take ClutchPoints through the unforgettable play, Manning delivered a perfect response:

“It worked out just how we planned it,” Manning joked. “We kind of told the linemen not to block anybody. And, you know, just, Eli, go be the superior athlete that you are, and, you know, throw it to Tyree's helmet.”

Manning continued the joke:

“So we practiced it all week and performed it just as it was expected to be executed.”

All these years later, it’s still regarded as one of the greatest catches and plays in Super Bowl history.

Eli on Thanksgiving with Peyton Manning and the family

Tom Brady and Peyton Manning had one of the NFL's greatest quarterback rivalries, facing off 17 times throughout their careers, with Brady holding an 11-6 overall advantage.

However, Manning had the edge when it mattered most, winning three of their five playoff matchups.

Brady also faced Eli five times in total, going 2-3 overall, with Eli, of course, winning those two Super Bowls (XLII and XLVI) in 2008 and 2012.

With Thanksgiving approaching, Manning was also asked whether he and Peyton revisit their legendary battles against Brady when the family gets together for the holidays.

Apparently, the three-time MVP and future Hall of Fame quarterback isn't a regular topic of conversation around the Manning family dinner table.

“Shockingly, Tom Brady doesn't come up a whole lot in our Thanksgiving and holiday meals,” Manning joked.

Instead, the family focuses on spending time together, catching up, and enjoying the opportunity to bring everyone under one roof.

“We have a lot of laughs. We all have our own kids and our own families. And just, you know, it's great to get the cousins together, the families together, and, you know, just enjoy being around each other,” Manning explained. “We all live in different parts of the world, so it's just good to get together and have some laughs.”

The hard-hitting question: Who wins when the Manning family gets together for a game in the backyard?

Manning had a pretty clear answer, especially with the next generation of the family making its way into the football spotlight.

“I think probably Arch wins it now, so we can't quite compete with him anymore,” Manning said.

From helping preserve the story of a football pioneer to reflecting on two championships that helped define his career, Manning continues to have plenty of connections to the game.

And while his legendary moments against Brady and the Patriots will always be part of his legacy, his latest project is helping ensure another important football story doesn't get forgotten.

—

Rob Lepelstat is an experienced sports media professional with over 7+ years in content creation, editorial, social media, reporting/interviewing, etc. His work has been featured in USA Today, Yahoo Sports, Bleacher Report, and more. Check out more of his interviews, including Jay-Z, Ice Cube, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Lawrence Taylor, Ray Lewis, Derek Jeter, “Dr. J” Julius Erving, Drew Brees, Ja'Marr Chase, Katie Ledecky, and Livvy Dunne here.