When news broke that Drake Maye's 2026 season was likely over after seemingly breaking his ankle in Germany on a sack by Aidan Hutchinson, fans of the New England Patriots began to scramble, looking for another signal-caller who can keep the season alive.
On popular name who has quickly emerged? Well that would be a player a past regime drafted in the second round all the way back in 2014: Jimmy Garoppolo. Discussing that popular theory on First Things First, former Patriots assistant coach Eric Mangini revealed why Garoppolo is the obvious man for the job, as he already has experience in Josh McDaniels' scheme.
“Yeah, absolutely. You got to make a move no matter what. You need another quarterback in the mix. To me where Jimmy Garoppolo makes so much sense is there's a long-term relationship between him and Josh McDaniels. He walks in, he knows the system. Not only does he know the system, but they have shared experience,” Mangini said.
“So you can draw on that. Very similar to what happened in Minnesota. And that is a gigantic edge. So you can go get a lot of guys and you bring a guy in, but they don't know your system. So there's a learning curve there. You don't know the player. So there's a learning curve from a coaching perspective. How quickly can they pick up the system? Saw that with Kyler Murray, when he went to Minnesota, all those question marks, none of those question marks exist with Garoppolo.”
All of that is well and good, but what if the Patriots firmly believe that DeVito is the guy to lead them down the stretch? Well, in that case, Mangini still believes Jimmy G can add value to the Patriots, as his experience playing for McDaniels could be just as beneficial in the locker room as on the field.
“Let's say you really like DeVito and you think he is the answer, and you bring in Garoppolo and you let him sit and be ready if you need him. That's another great answer if DeVito gets hurt,” Mangini noted. “We saw Baltimore lost two quarterbacks in one game. So it's not beyond the realm of possibility even from that angle. The other edge is Garoppolo could come in and actually help DeVito in the room because he is experienced in the system. He is a veteran quarterback. He has won games.”
Is there a world where Garoppolo dusts off his old No. 10 jersey and gets back to work in New England? Considering Maye currently has those digits locked down, the answer to that question is a resounding no, but in another number? That really might be the case, especially if McDaniels, Mike Vrabel, and company want a veteran option instead of a young arm like DeVito or Will Levis.
Coach Mangini says the Patriots should absolutely make a move for another QB:
“To me, where Jimmy Garoppolo makes so much sense is there’s a long term relationship between him and Josh McDaniels. He walks in, he knows the system.” pic.twitter.com/a1nx5MJKAA
— First Things First (@FTFonFS1) November 18, 2026

