Duke doesn’t look like the powerhouse it was supposed to be entering the season.

(Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)
Getty Images
Ricky O'Donnell has covered basketball at all levels for more than a decade at SB Nation. He’s currently the Associate Director of Programming.

The annual inevitability of Duke’s greatness had fully creeped deeper into the mainstream consensus as the 2026-27 men’s college basketball season neared. The Athletic ranked Duke as the preseason No. 1 team in the country, and wrote that their chemistry would be their only real challenge. Dick Vitale said Duke’s bench “could be a top-20 team in the nation.” On3 Sports ranked 17-year-old incoming freshman Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje as the best player in college basketball despite the fact that he wouldn’t be old enough to enter the NBA Draft until 2028.

Jon Scheyer liked his team so much that he turned down an offer to jump to the NBA to coach Cooper Flagg and the Dallas Mavericks. “I believe in my soul that we’re going to win a national championship here soon,” Scheyer told ESPN at the onset of the season.

Just about the only thing holding back Duke was the pesky fact that college basketball coronations don’t happen in the fall. The Blue Devils were always going to have so much competition to eventually cut down the nets, and there were real reasons to believe this team wouldn’t enjoy the same advantages as their predecessors the last two seasons. These realities comforted Duke in the face during the first true test of the season last week, when Michigan State smacked them around for 40 minutes on the way to a sobering 79-73 defeat that wasn’t as close as the final score might have indicated.

The Spartans punched Duke in the mouth from the opening tip, and they were unable to fight back. MSU star Jeremy Fears Jr. completely out-classed Duke’s calvary of guards, the Blue Devils’ outside shooting looked suspect, and Boumtje Boumtje was unable to meet the moment. After having the best player on the floor in every game the last two years with Cooper Flagg and Cameron Boozer, Duke suddenly looked like a regular ole’ college basketball team full of good players but devoid a real chessmaster to carry them over the top.

There are real reasons to believe the Blue Devils might not be the juggernaut they were hyped to be even after a convincing victory over SIU-Edwardsville in their next game. Duke seems to have some real problems right now, especially when you consider that anything other than a Final Four berth will ultimately count as a bust of a season.

Duke needs to figure out how to leverage Boumtje Boumtje’s gifts

I was fully bought into the hype on Boumtje Boumtje after watching his stellar run in the FIBA U19 World Cup over the summer. I called JBB the best NBA prospect in the world, but I wasn’t certain he’d immediately become an impact player at the college level, leaving him off my preseason ranking of the top-20 players in the sport. For as bright as Boumtje Boumtje’s future is, his present state could provide Duke with more questions than answers.

Duke is listing their star freshman at 7’2, 250 pounds. I’ll take the under on that height measurement when he actually stands up to a tape measure — lying about your height might just be a Duke tradition — but it doesn’t change that fact that Boumtje Boumtje is massive. To start the season, Duke has him at the four playing next to a traditional five in Patrick Ngongba. The idea is that JBB’s knockdown three-point shooting would give the Blue Devils enough spacing to go with double bigs as a standard alignment, but the MSU loss revealed some other ways the paring is hurting the team.

Boumtje Boumtje is simply too slow to defend the nominal wings that play the four in college hoops, and there were multiple times against Michigan State when it seemed like he had cement blocks tied to his feet. Offensively, he was mostly reduced to spacing the floor from the corners, and rarely factored into the primary action. Even crashing the offensive glass became a dicey proposition, because then he’d need to race back downcourt to chase an assignment who had a speed advantage on him.

I just didn’t like the way the Ngongba-JBB pairing looked for Duke: it was too limited off the dribble on offense and too slow on both ends. I didn’t count a single time where Duke had Boumtje Boumtje as the lone big man on the floor either, instead inserting Drew Scharnowski next to him when Ngongba went to the bench. One easy fix is to stagger the bigs in the minutes when Ngongba is resting to put more speed and more creation around both of their star bigs for stretches of the game. Yes, Boumtje Boumtje would be a target defensively at the five, but he should be able to get it back offensively with elite spacing and shooting for a center. I also think he can do more off the dribble against slower-footed fives, and his passing ability could be utilized more effectively, as well.

Boumtje Boumtje needs to be used on pick-and-pops where he can fire threes over bigs who are slower to recover to his shot, or put the ball on the floor to attack the closeout. He needs to take a page out of Karl-Anthony Towns’ — his closest pro comparison to my eyes — book at Kentucky and play a little bit more in the post. He needs to be involved in more action instead of essentially being reduced to a release valve.

Boumtje Boumtje has not hit the ground running the way his top competition for the No. 1 overall pick in the 2028 NBA Draft, UCLA forward Nikola Kusturica, has. That’s fine. His talent is immense; Duke just needs to figure out his role.

Duke’s guards might be mediocre

Almost every national champion of the last two decades has had an elite point guard at the controls. It’s fair to be skeptical that Duke has anyone who fits that mold after watching the way the entire backcourt was outplayed by Fears.

Duke has a lot of guards with different levels of skill and experience in the backcourt even without a lead dog. There’s sophomore Cayden Boozer, seniors Caleb Foster and Wisconsin transfer John Blackwell, and freshman Deron Rippey Jr. Blackwell is the best shooter, Rippey is obviously the most explosive athlete, Boozer feels like the best facilitator, and Foster is the biggest and might be the most well-rounded. It just doesn’t feel like Duke has anyone yet with true ownership over the position who could reliably create a shot in the biggest moments against the best defenses.

Teams will continue to go under screens on Boozer until he shows outside shooting improvement, and that clogs up driving and cutting lanes for everyone else. Blackwell can rise and fire from mid-range or three, but he has nearly as many turnovers (169) as assists (185) during his college career, and just doesn’t have the passing vision of the best lead guards. Foster is likely relegated to a bench role all season, and Rippey can bend a defense with his speed but needs to continue fine-tuning his feel for the game.

It still feels like Duke’s best shot creators are probably the big men, Ngongba and Boumtje Boumtje. The good news is that it’s a long season, and Duke has enough talent in the guard room that someone could eventually break out as the lead guy. They just aren’t there yet.

Does Duke have enough shooting?

The Blue Devils have struggled to shoot the ball from deep in three of their four games so far. They have a lot of guys who can theoretically threaten the defense with their three-point shot, but they don’t have too many guys opposing teams will be scared of.

Duke is making only 30.4% of their threes right now, which ranks No. 232 in the country. It only shot 4-of-22 from three against Army, 9-of-29 against SIUE, and 7-of-29 against MSU. Right now, Duke is taking 41.3% of its field goal attempts from three, which seems higher than it is. It only ranks No. 182 in the country.

The one thing that would really boost Duke’s shooting is a leap from sophomore wing Dame Sarr, who needs to be on the floor a lot for his defense and athleticism. Sarr made 32.3% of his threes on 133 attempts from deep as a freshman last year. He’s off to a cold stat, but certainly has the talent to perk up as the season goes on. Blackwell made a big shooting leap last season, going from 32.2% (on 180 attempts) as a sophomore at Wisconsin to 39% on 247 attempts as a junior. He needs to be shooting like he did last year for Duke to scare teams from the outside.

The final piece is Boumtje Boumtje, who could be one of the most dangerous front court shooters in the country if he can figure out his place on this team soon.

Duke should be very good, but they need to be great to avoid being a disappointment

Scheyer proved himself as a top coach when he took the 2024 team to the Elite Eight as a No. 4 seed. He followed that up the next year by his team to the Final Four, but it still felt like a disappointment given the overall talent level with three lottery picks in Flagg, Kon Knueppel, and Khaman Maluach. Last year’s team had a great chance to win it all behind Cameron Boozer, but they were stunned in the Elite Eight by UConn on Braylon Mullins’ buzzer-beater.

This team was supposed to be among the country’s best, right there with Florida and Illinois and UConn. Michigan State was also in the top-5 of the preseason rankings, and they clearly looked better on a neutral floor. The point of games like the Champions Classic or the showdown this week against the Illini is to measure yourself against the best of the best early in the season, and grow from there. It’s already clear that Duke has a lot of growing left to do.

All of your communities in one place.