SAN DIEGO -- There’s probably no other team that needs starting pitching more urgently than the San Diego Padres.
Tarik Skubal is the best free-agent pitcher on the market.
That’s the fit. Simple enough.
Skubal, of course, would boost every rotation in baseball. But for a team that needs both a front-line ace and innings coverage -- a team squarely in win-now mode, but woefully short on starting pitching -- let’s just say there’s good reason for the Padres to be interested.
But how realistic is a match? Per reports, the two sides are set to meet this week. An eventful bidding process lies ahead.
Right now, it’s unlikely …
Let’s start with what’s probably obvious: It’s far likelier Skubal signs elsewhere. The Padres have never given out a contract to a pitcher greater than the six-year, $108 million deal Yu Darvish signed before the 2022 season. Skubal will command far more than that. Perhaps more than triple that.
There are other heavily involved suitors as well, and after last week’s General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas, MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand noted: “If there was one glaring takeaway from this week, it’s that nearly everybody in the game expects Skubal to sign with the Mets.”
Per multiple reports, the Mets met with Skubal earlier this week, and they seem to remain the favorites. The Dodgers and Blue Jays are in the mix as well -- and presumably a handful of mystery teams. (Again, who wouldn’t want Skubal, a two-time Cy Young Award winner and arguably the best pitcher in the sport over the past four seasons?)
Padres on the hunt
General manager A.J. Preller has never been shy about going after big-name stars. He wooed Manny Machado and Xander Bogaerts. He traded for Juan Soto (then traded him away). He once revamped his entire rotation by trading for Darvish, Blake Snell and Joe Musgrove in the span of days.
Still, over the past couple offseasons, the Padres haven’t been nearly as active in the free-agent market.
This winter might be different. New ownership is in place and -- from, quite literally, the very start -- has expressed an “all-in” approach. Beyond that, the Padres have contracts coming off the books this winter, and a few more set to do so in the near future. There seems to be room to spend. At last week’s GM Meetings, Preller touted the investment of new owners Kwanza Jones and José E. Feliciano.
“They’re very open that they’re committed to putting a winning team on the field,” Preller said. “Exactly what form that looks like, how much the exact dollars are -- I think that’s a little player-specific.”
Parallels to Machado?
The Machado deal might be the best comparison. Alongside Bryce Harper, Machado was right at the top of free-agent class of the 2018-19 offseason. The Padres entered the winter with no expectation they would end up at the forefront of Machado’s market. But they grew more involved when they realized what that market was. Specifically: They saw value.
Later that winter, Machado signed a record-setting 10-year, $300 million deal with San Diego. At the time, it was the largest contract in North American sports history. That deal ended up aging extremely well.
Skubal, too, might command a record-setting contract, perhaps the largest given to a pitcher (not counting Shohei Ohtani). It’s the type of money some teams might have reservations about, specifically for a pitcher about to turn 30.
So while other teams can almost certainly outbid the Padres, as we saw with Machado, that doesn’t necessarily mean that they will.
A myth about Skubal and the rotation search
Do the Padres need to add three starting pitchers? Or is it four? Those questions were posed to Preller at last week’s GM meetings, and a wry grin crossed his face.
“Keep going,” Preller said.
The Padres need both quality and quantity here. They’ve got the makings of an elite bullpen and a strong offensive foundation. They could be World Series contenders next season with a solid rotation.
But right now, they have almost no rotation whatsoever. Randy Vásquez is the only surefire returnee. Even if the Padres were to add Skubal, one of the best pitchers in the sport, they would still face major rotation questions.
Does that make it less likely they would go hard after Skubal? And more likely they’d spread their resources around? I’m not so sure. Not with Preller’s penchant for swinging big -- and for finding deals on back-of-the-rotation-type starters, then developing them into front-line options under pitching coach Ruben Niebla. (Think: Nick Pivetta, Seth Lugo, Nick Martinez, etc.)
What to expect?
Ultimately, however, spreading those resources around is the likeliest outcome. As Feinsand implied, it’s just much likelier that Skubal will land elsewhere.
That would leave the Padres to explore other options. Perhaps they’ll reunite with King and Pivetta. Perhaps looking at other frontline starters. Maybe they’ll pull off a trade. This being Preller, maybe two or three of those routes.
At the GM meetings, Preller was asked if the top of the free agent market would be in play for him. Translation: Is Skubal in play? It’s already abundantly clear that the Padres are interested in the next tier of players after Skubal -- the group that features, among others, King, Adrian Morejon, Freddy Peralta, Seiya Suzuki and Teruaki Sato.
“That’s what this week and the next couple weeks is about,” Preller replied. “It’s just kind of [about] figuring out what that means, what the market is and what the dollars are for each player.”
In other words, there’s a limit to how far they’ll go in the Skubal sweepstakes. But, yes, the Padres remain interested. As they should be.

