Even after the Indianapolis Colts ended a five-game losing streak with a 24-22 victory over the Miami Dolphins in Week 10, questions about quarterback Daniel Jones' performance remained. He threw two interceptions and barely surpassed 108 passing yards, prompting ongoing speculation about why he is still the starter. Head coach Shane Steichen deflected inquiries about Jones' $88 million contract while praising his preparation and leadership each week.

While Steichen publicly attributed the team's struggles to overall execution and play-calling, insiders suggest that the main reason for keeping Jones as the starter is the coaching staff's evident lack of confidence in the players behind him on the depth chart. A report from ESPN's Jeremy Fowler revealed the coaching staff's reluctance to play former 2023 fourth overall pick Anthony Richardson Jr., who has fallen out of favor following a promising start to his rookie season. Fowler noted that neither Richardson nor third-string quarterback Riley Leonard impressed the coaching staff during training camp, and this evaluation has effectively sidelined Richardson unless an injury forces him into action before he approaches free agency in 2027.

As speculation swirls about the team's future, especially following the firing of general manager Chris Ballard, Jones has responded to the ongoing discussions about his potential benching with measured accountability. After the win, he addressed reporters through The Athletic's James Boyd, acknowledging the reality of his situation: “I understand how it works in this league and the job—all of it. You’re expected to play well…so I understand what happens when I don’t, and I’ve got to be better.”