Camryn Bynum thought he had just delivered a momentum-changing play for the Indianapolis Colts. However, Thursday night’s matchup against the Houston Texans quickly turned his latest celebration into an unfortunate blooper. With 5:54 remaining in the second quarter and Indianapolis trailing 14-3, Bynum jumped a CJ Stroud pass intended for Tank Dell at the Houston 38-yard line. Bynum seemingly secured an interception before returning it three yards to the 35. Convinced he had grabbed his 13th career pick, the Colts safety immediately broke out one of his trademark choreographed celebrations. It added another potential viral moment to his growing collection of turnover theatrics.

Catch or Drop? #Colts Cam Bynum was so close on this

Pens it to the chest but comes lose after the ground pic.twitter.com/dDdUvgYqSB

— FirstDownMedia (@FirstDownMediaa) November 20, 2026

Unfortunately for Bynum, the excitement was premature. Replay officials took another look at the interception. Slow-motion angles showed the ball coming loose as he hit the ground. Although Bynum initially pinned the football against his chest, he failed to maintain possession through the landing. This prompted officials to overturn the call and rule the pass incomplete. The reversal wiped away both the interception and Indianapolis’ opportunity to take over in promising field position. It left Bynum with a celebration that ultimately counted for nothing.

Houston punted two plays later, further minimizing the Colts’ chances of capitalizing on the apparent defensive breakthrough. Bynum’s instincts were right. He read Stroud’s throw and positioned himself perfectly to make the play. The replay booth, though, had the final say.

Indianapolis entered Thursday’s contest at 3-7 following a turbulent season marked by a five-game losing streak. They have also undergone a midseason front-office shakeup, major trades, and defensive struggles. After snapping its skid against Miami in Week 10, the Colts were hoping to build momentum. Bynum’s overturned pick, though, served as a frustrating reminder that every play still needs to be finished.