Why the CFP Committee must be more transparent after rankings controversies

(Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)
Getty Images

Alabama is 8-2. UCLA is 10-0. And in the latest College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings that were released on Tuesday night, the Crimson Tide came in one spot (No. 3) ahead of the Bruins (No. 4) for a second straight week.

That is just one of the many things that has fueled debate the last couple weeks about whether the CFP committee favors the SEC over the Big Ten, Big 12 and ACC. I don’t believe the answer is as simple as them being biased, but I also understand why people could think they are.

Because much like when Nate Bargatze was asked how many liters are in a gallon, or how many yards are in a mile in the “Washington’s Dream” sketch on Saturday Night Live, “nobody knows” what the CFP committee values when it comes to their rankings.

The fix for this should be simple: tell everyone how you go about determining the rankings. Or, more bluntly, which advanced metrics are used to help rank the top-25 teams.

When asked about that very thing earlier this week by The Athletic, CFP executive director Rich Clark danced around the question a bit and ultimately said this:

“Just to let you know, we have not provided those publicly. Basically, there’s so many metrics to really give that out publicly with an explanation of them isn’t really feasible right now. It is something that we’re considering. We’re looking at this in the offseason to see what metrics and how we would present those potentially in the coming seasons.”

The committee is not hiding the fact it uses metrics to help set their rankings, but why not tell fans how many, and which, metrics are used? And which ones are the most important? And how were those metrics determined to be more important than the others?

And how is it not “feasible” to simply say which metrics you use? Perhaps Clark means it isn’t feasible to show every metric in a clean, TV-friendly graphic. Maybe not. But with ESPN holding the CFP’s media rights through the 2031 season, it’s fair to wonder how much input the network has in what the public sees.

Nobody knows.

One metric we know the CFP values is strength of schedule. Committee Chair Hunter Yurachek — the athletic director for Arkansas — has defended Alabama’s ranking due to the Crimson Tide’s schedule. They rank sixth in strength of record and sixth in strength of schedule on ESPN’s Football Power Index (FPI).

That may be a fine and dandy explanation to a casual college football fan, but ESPN owns the media rights to the CFP, so using ESPN’s own metrics is really suspect.

Other than that, what else does the committee value? Head-to-head results don’t really appear to be one of them. CBS Sports noted the committee has valued head-to-head results in some cases, like Alabama over Kentucky, but not in others.

One prime example is…you guessed it…Alabama being six spots ahead of Tennessee despite the Volunteers beating the Tide by 16 points this season. Yurachek explained that decision by citing Alabama’s three wins over teams in the committee’s top-25.

Now, to be fair, the metrics do back up the strength of schedule debate in Alabama’s favor. UCLA is first in strength of record, but just 67th in strength of schedule. With a non-conference schedule that featured teams like San Diego State (96th in FPI) Cal (97th) and Nevada (98th), that isn’t incredibly surprising.

Alabama’s non-conference schedule wasn’t much better. Florida State (No. 40) is a shell of what it once was and is in the midst of a coaching search, and East Carolina (No. 89) and FCS Chattanooga don’t move the needle either. At least not to the point where they should definitively be ahead of the Bruins with two losses.

If the strength of schedule and strength of record metrics are what the committee favors more than others, just say it. A published methodology protects the committee more than this current approach does. Instead, every close call we get currently in the rankings can look like a favor to ESPN and the SEC.

But perhaps it isn’t the strength of schedule that matters; perhaps it’s strength of schedule within a team’s conference. ESPN’s Heather Dinich said on Tuesday night’s show that there is a “new metric” the committee is using this year to help them rank each team. And the metric certainly seems to favor schools where football “just means more.”

So the reason No. 21 South Carolina is still ranked — even after losing last week, 34-6, to an Arkansas team (Yurachek’s Arkansas team, just to remind you) that was 3-6 and had lost four of its last five games before that game — is because…the SEC’s schedule is tougher? According to who, exactly? Who determines how difficult a conference’s schedule really is?

Nobody knows, but it must also be the reason three other four-loss teams — No. 22 Oklahoma, No. 24 Florida, No. 25 Ole Miss — are also ranked.

Ultimately, the CFP Committee needs to be transparent before the college football season even begins. Members of the committee change every year, so the way they go about developing the rankings should be made available every offseason so we all know exactly what to expect. Then, if the committee changes their criteria midseason, those changes should be made public as well, along with legitimate reasons for why those changes were made.

Show your work, CFP Committee. Fans can handle it.

Everybody knows that.

All of your communities in one place.