The St. Louis Cardinals are reportedly making the decision to non-tender infielder Nolan Gorman, per Joel Sherman of the New York Post. Gorman, who once was a star prospect, is set to enter MLB free agency.

Fans have been hoping for Gorman to break out for years now. He's displayed potential at times, but Gorman's overall inconsistency has been difficult to ignore.

The 26-year-old made his big league debut in 2022. Expectations were high for Gorman. He endured an up and down rookie season that saw him appear in 89 games. Gorman played in 119 games during the '23 campaign, hitting 27 home runs and turning in an .805 OPS. It seemed as if he was close to truly breaking out.

He's failed to record an OPS above .700 since that season, though. Gorman's 2026 season was especially difficult, as he spent some of it in the minor leagues. At the big league level, he hit just .184 with a .580 OPS in 85 total games.

Article Continues Below

The non-tender decision was likely difficult despite Gorman's struggles. At only 26 years old, the idea of Gorman finding his footing soon is still realistic. In the end, the Cardinals made a decision that they felt was best for the team moving forward.

Gorman should draw interest in MLB free agency given his ceiling. He is also fairly versatile, as he can play second or third base. Teams in need of a starter or left-handed hitting platoon option at either position may have interest. Ball clubs looking for overall infield depth could end up inquiring as well.