The story of the season, at least for most of it, has been the average play of many of the quarterback prospects around college football. The 2027 NFL Draft quarterback class was billed as one of the best in recent memory coming into the 2026 season, and now it looks a whole lot like all of the other ones.
Saturday certainly didn't help that narrative. Seemingly all of the top quarterback prospects in college football had some of their worst games of the season over the weekend, and their stock all took a bit of a hit as a result. Of course, at this point in the season and in their careers, one game doesn't change your draft stock all that much, but a lot of weaknesses were put on display once again for a lot of these prospects.
Even Drew Mestemaker, who has emerged as the pretty clear No. 1 QB prospect over the course of the season, had one of his worst games on Saturday in a loss to Texas Tech. Trinidad Chambliss had one of his worst games in a loss to Oklahoma in a game that got moved to Sunday. Austin Simmons was the latest to get chewed up and spit out by an elite Georgia defense, and Arch Manning had a brutal night before rebounding somewhat in a win over LSU.
How did all of that affect the latest 2027 NFL Draft QB rankings?
1. Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State

Last week: 1
Mestemaker struggled on Saturday night against a Texas Tech defense that challenged some of his strengths. First of all, the talented Red Raiders defensive line was able to get interior pressure and push Mestemaker back in the pocket, and the very good linebacker group for Joey McGuire and company took away the intermediate throwing lanes that Mestemaker loves to access over the middle of the field.
The numbers are pretty ugly. The potential No. 1 pick was pressured on 17 dropbacks, finishing 6-of-12 with 82 yards and two interceptions while taking four sacks on those plays. That's just too many negative plays for someone who could be leading an NFL offense next season, even if he wasn't getting a ton of help from the rest of the offense around him.
This game was a reminder of just how raw and inexperienced Mestemaker is as a quarterback. He still has a lot of growing to do, despite his talent, and games like this one could be a big reason why he could be going back to school next season.
2. LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina
Last week: 2
Sellers didn't play on Saturday in what ended up being a bizarre saga that ultimately cost South Carolina its chance at a College Football Playoff berth. If anything, the star quarterback looks even more valuable after missing Saturday's game with an ankle injury. The South Carolina offense couldn't do just about anything in a 34-6 loss to an Arkansas team that likely won't be playing in a bowl game this season.
Sellers may have widened his gap at No. 2 this week after some of the poor performances from the players below him. Assuming he is back on the field in Week 12, he will get a crack at No. 1 Georgia in a home game on Saturday night.
3. Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss
Last week: 3
Ole Miss' season is officially over after the Rebels limped into Norman on Sunday afternoon after the FAA ground stoppage, only to get strangled in a 24-17 loss to a bad Oklahoma team. Chambliss played pretty poorly against a good Oklahoma defense, something that has become a little bit more common of late, finishing 14-of-27 passing for 127 yards and a touchdown. The Sooners defense made everything downfield tough on Chambliss and took all of the explosiveness out of the Rebels' passing game.
Chambliss was effective as a runner and a scrambler in this game, turning 11 carries into 84 yards on the day. That will continue to be an asset to his draft profile, but the flaws he continues to show as a passer are going to limit his draft upside this spring.
4. Darian Mensah, Miami (FL)

Last week: 4
Mensah is one of the few players on this list that had a great day on Saturday, and the Hurricanes needed every bit of it. Miami faced a stiff challenge from a seven-win Duke team over the weekend without Malachi Toney, and running back Mark Fletcher got banged up during this game as well. Mensah still finished the day with 382 passing yards and a touchdown on 30-of-41 passing.
The Miami signal-caller hasn't been pushing the ball down the field a whole lot. Only 10 of his attempts on Saturday went beyond 10 yards downfield, but he is a good processor who gets the ball out on time underneath. That can work in the NFL, and Mensah continues to look like a future starter in the league.
5. Austin Simmons, Missouri
Last week: 5
Simmons didn't have his best day against Georgia in a game where Missouri was completely overmatched. He threw a pretty inexcusable interception on the Tigers' opening drive of the evening, and they were completely behind the 8-ball from there.
At this point, it looks more likely that Simmons honors his 2027 deal to return to Missouri and is a 2028 draft prospect. If he comes back to college next season, he will get to work on his decision making and just keeping the offense on schedule more often. If he would take his medicine on early downs a little bit more, this Missouri offense would be able to be a little bit more consistent and have better results overall. Adding that to his incredible arm talent would make him a threat to go in the top 10 in 2028.
6. C.J. Carr, Notre Dame
Last week: 7
Carr and Notre Dame had another easy day against Boston College, rolling through the Eagles 41-7. Even in bad weather, Carr's precision and accuracy were on full display. His advanced processing and understanding of where the ball needs to go helps Notre Dame churn through a lot of the bad defenses on their schedule, but it remains to be seen whether it can lift the Irish to a national title against the best defenses in the nation. At this point, Carr is still a high floor, low ceiling draft prospect, which lands him in the middle of these rankings.
7. Arch Manning, Texas

Last week: 6
Manning is just a tough evaluation, and it looks like that evaluation is going to bleed into next season if he does end up going back to school. On Saturday night, his flaws were on full display. Manning's willingness to push the ball down the field is an asset at times, even in muddy pockets, but sometimes it borders on recklessness and it did so in Death Valley. Manning constantly put the Texas defense in bad positions with costly interceptions, and those mistakes looked a lot like many others he has made this year.
There is still some good here. Manning's pocket movement is some of the best in this class and he still makes some great throws, even in a bad game like this. He excels in big moments at the end of games, a trait that is overrated that still counts for something. But there's just too much bad here, and the bad is really bad. That's going to keep him from rising up on this list.
Article Continues Below8. Dante Moore, Oregon
Last week: 8
Moore's Ducks continued to chug along with a dominant win over Michigan on Saturday. Oregon, still with just three losses on the season, has a chance to sneak into the College Football Playoff if they can get a little bit more help around the country over the next two weeks. There's even a chance Oregon can get into the Big Ten Championship Game with some help around the conference.
It's unlikely Moore will return to the field this year even if Oregon gets into the CFP in about a month's time, but it would be a very interesting storyline if he did. For now, he remains at No. 8 here.
9. Brendan Sorsby
Last week: 9
Sorsby stays at No. 9 once again as the quarterbacks below him fail to perform well enough to move ahead of him. At this point, it's looking likely that the will finish the year in the top 10 on this list despite not playing all year due to his gambling scandal.
10. Jayden Maiava, USC
Last week: 10
Maiava and USC absolutely had to have a win in a hostile environment on Saturday against Indiana, and the star quarterback simply left too many things on the table for the Trojans to pull off the upset. He racked up 311 yards and a touchdown on the afternoon, but three costly interceptions hurt USC in a 27-13 loss that was much closer than the final score suggests.
Maiava continues to make too many of those critical mistakes to overlook for someone with a pretty average physical profile. As good as it looks when he starts to get hot, it can be equally as frustrating when defenses have him a little bit confused like Indiana did on Saturday.
Next five: Conner Weigman (Houston), Drake Lindsey (Minnesota), Gunner Stockton (Georgia), Julian Sayin (Ohio State), Nico Iamaleava (UCLA)

