Despite boasting an explosive top-six offense anchored by Donovan Mitchell, James Harden, Evan Mobley, and Jarrett Allen, the Cleveland Cavaliers have stumbled out of the gates to an underwhelming 9-8 start. After reaching the Eastern Conference Finals last spring, Cleveland currently sits seventh in the East and ranks just 21st in defensive rating a sluggish opening month that has quietly put head coach Kenny Atkinson on notice. While Harden erupted for 51 points against Indiana to snap a mini-skid, Cleveland’s perimeter defense and wing scoring remain dangerously thin behind offseason pickup Peyton Watson and sharpshooter Sam Merrill.
If team president Koby Altman wants to stabilize Atkinson’s rotation and rescue Cleveland’s championship aspirations before the pressure mounts, he should strike early and target New Orleans Pelicans forward Trey Murphy III.
The Proposed Deal
Cleveland Cavaliers receive:
- Trey Murphy III
New Orleans Pelicans receive:
- Peyton Watson
- Sam Merrill
- 2030 first-round pick
- 2032 first-round pick swap
Why Trey Murphy III Transforms Cleveland’s Ceiling

Cleveland’s biggest flaw early this season is glaringly obvious: opponents routinely target a small backcourt of Mitchell and Harden while daring Cleveland’s role players to beat them from the perimeter. Adding Murphy III solves both problems in a single stroke.
At 6-foot-8 and 26 years old, Murphy III is blossoming into one of the league’s premier two-way wings, averaging 15.7 points, 4.7 rebounds, and 3.3 assists per game in New Orleans this season while draining high-volume three-pointers. Under Atkinson’s pace-and-space system, Murphy III would thrive as a lethal off-ball weapon who punishes defenses whenever teams blitz Mitchell or Harden in pick-and-rolls. Just as importantly, his length and athleticism give Cleveland a reliable point-of-attack defender who can check top Eastern Conference wings like Jayson Tatum and OG Anunoby without forcing Mobley to constantly abandon the paint.
Article Continues BelowWhy the Deal Makes Sense for Both Front Offices
Because the Cavaliers sit right at the first tax apron and comfortably beneath the second apron, they are permitted to combine multiple contracts in a deal allowing Cleveland to package Peyton Watson ($20.5 million) and Sam Merrill ($9.2 million) to absorb Murphy III’s $27.0 million salary while actually shaving money off their payroll and staying compliant with the Stepien Rule by sending an unprotected 2030 first-round pick alongside a 2032 swap.
For a rebuilding New Orleans franchise stuck near the bottom of the Western Conference with little direction, the offer is hard to refuse. Moving Murphy III early nets the Pelicans a 24-year-old defensive stopper in Watson, an affordable floor-spacer in Merrill, and coveted future draft equity to accelerate their reset.
Cleveland cannot afford to waste the prime years of Mitchell and Mobley while letting defensive leaks sink its season. Landing Murphy III early takes the heat off Atkinson and turns the Cavaliers back into a legitimate title threat.

