The New Orleans Saints have an enormous choice to make.
With Derek Carr surprisingly retiring earlier than the beginning of the season, they now need to roll with a younger quarterback.
Notably, Spencer Rattler hasn’t regarded good in his transient time within the league, and whereas he can nonetheless turn into stable, he simply doesn’t look prepared.
For NFL analyst Greg Cosell, nonetheless, that wasn’t the case with Tyler Shough.
Speaking on the Ross Tucker Podcast, Cosell had nothing however constructive issues to say in regards to the Louisville product.
“I hate to be cliched, however he took the throws that ‘the protection gave him’ that had been clear throws,” Cosell stated.
“I hate to be cliched, however he took the throws that ‘the protection gave him’ that had been clear throws.”@GregCosell was impressed with Tyler Shough’s Saints preseason debut: pic.twitter.com/afROPi4QRP
— Ross Tucker Podcast (@RossTuckerPod) August 17, 2025
Shough will get an opportunity to start out in Sunday’s preseason recreation vs. the Jacksonville Jaguars.
He’s competing with Rattler for the beginning quarterback job, and whereas the pattern dimension is kind of small, he regarded significantly better in his first style of NFL motion.
Rattler performed many of the first half of the preseason opener vs. the Los Angeles Chargers, and he accomplished 7 of 11 passes for 53 yards.
Shough took the sector for the ultimate two minutes of the primary half and performed many of the second half.
He accomplished 15 of twenty-two passes for 165 yards with one passing landing and a pick-six.
The Saints are projected to be one of many worst groups within the league final season, they usually’re greater than only one quarterback away from turning that narrative round.
Even so, and whereas Shough was a polarizing prospect due to his age and historical past of accidents, he might give this workforce a greater probability to compete than Rattler, at the least in the meanwhile.
NEXT: Chad Johnson Raises Massive Query To Saints Followers About QB State of affairs